SUMMARY With current implementation[1] of Kirigami.Dialog, dialog footer's implicit size is not honored, so it's possible to get a dialog smaller than what footer wanted to be. Regardless of that Kirigami issue, Kirigami.Dialog is a subtype of QQC2 Templates Popup, so it's constrained by its parent window size minus margins, so dialog can't count on its implicit size being honored anyway. The problem is, qqc2-desktop-style implementation of DialogButtonBox is not adaptive to explicit size constraints: 1. It does not clip its buttons, so they overflow; 2. They don't scroll horizontally, even though they are in a ListView; 3. The less space you give to DialogButtonBox to accommodate itself, the more it moves to the left. o_O STEPS TO REPRODUCE 1. Run snippet[2] in qmlscene 2. Resize window (shrink, stretch) OBSERVED RESULT a) Without Kirigami patch, Dialog is zero-width. It does not respect footer size, so all its DialogButtonBox buttons are invisible. With Kirigami patch, only right dialog's "Yahaha" button is visible which does not belong to DialogButtonBox anyway (added through customFooterActions). b) DialogButtonBox moves to the left when there is no enough space for it, i.e. width < implicitWidth. EXPECTED RESULT DialogButtonBox should not move to the left, leaving empty space on the right. DialogButtonBox should react "properly" to width constraints, either wrapping in multiple lines, or scrolling horizontally, or both. SOFTWARE/OS VERSIONS Operating System: Arch Linux KDE Plasma Version: git-master (kf5) Qt Version: 5.15.8 Kernel Version: 6.1.11-arch1-1 (64-bit) Graphics Platform: X11 ADDITIONAL INFORMATION [1]: https://invent.kde.org/frameworks/kirigami/-/issues/41 [2]: https://invent.kde.org/frameworks/qqc2-desktop-style/-/snippets/2508
Created attachment 156367 [details] DialogButtonBox - moving to the left
Created attachment 156368 [details] DialogButtonBox - moving to the left
Oh the humanity!