Created attachment 136398 [details] Window decorations are not aplied for GTK apps with CSD When I set "Oxygen" or "Plastik" window decoration in settings, GTK apps with CSD are not affected at all and still use breeze window decoration even if the app is closed then reopened. See attached image for more info. Operating System: Manjaro Linux KDE Plasma Version: 5.21.1 KDE Frameworks Version: 5.79.0 Qt Version: 5.15.2 Kernel Version: 5.4.100-1-MANJARO OS Type: 64-bit
do you have kde-gtk-config installed?
This is a known shortcoming in the decoration exporter, supporting these decorations will require a significant amount of extra effort.
Oof.
Plastic is indeed won't work, because it's too much effort to support (If someone want, they can create a MR). Oxygen on the other hand should be supported, AFAIK it's draws itself just like breeze. When I created this functionality I tested it, so I'm surprised.
It seems you're right. However, I noticed that if in kwinrc, "library" is "org.kde.oxygen" but "theme" is corrupted or absent, KWin will render Oxygen, but Breeze buttons will be exported to GTK. @medin, could you check whether this is the culprit for you?
(In reply to Nate Graham from comment #1) > do you have kde-gtk-config installed? Yeah, I have kde-gtk-config v5.21.1-1 installed.
(In reply to Alois Wohlschlager from comment #5) > It seems you're right. However, I noticed that if in kwinrc, "library" is > "org.kde.oxygen" but "theme" is corrupted or absent, KWin will render > Oxygen, but Breeze buttons will be exported to GTK. @medin, could you check > whether this is the culprit for you? With Oxygen decoration it seems to work but not correctly, the shadow is not the same as oxygen it remains black like breeze, and maximize/minimize/close buttons are much smaller. See attached image for more info.
Created attachment 136409 [details] Oxygen decorations GTK apps with CSD
I have no idea about the shadow unfortunately. Regarding the size of the buttons, this is actually an issue with Breeze and Aurorae as well and I will try to figure out a solution.
Firefox is also affected with this bug, it does not apply Plastik decoration, and applies Oxygen incorrectly. While Chromium (GTK theme) does not even apply shadow with any KDE plasma theme but suffers from titlebar icons problems as Firefox.
Let's confine this bug report to the Plastik issue. The button size thing is something I know of. Please file a separate bug for the shadow issue. These reason why separate issues should be filed separately is that we will need separate fixes for them, and this is very hard to keep track of in a single bug report.