Created attachment 112002 [details] showing QMessageBox Question with new icon and kdialog with old icon The QMessageBox Question icon has changed in lastest Git master breeze icons. This is a multi layered issue and it's unclear quite what's going on. There was a new dialog-question icon added for Kirigami which is a smaller size (22). This is the new icon that is being used, it's line art while the old one is coloured purple. The attached screenshot shows it. One qustion is should this icon as displayed on a QMessageBox use the line art version or the solid version. VDG will have some breeze guidelines on the style of icon to be used in this case. Another question is why is QMessagebox Question using that 22 icon, QStyle plugin doesn't specify a size but defaults to 32px, there are no 32px icons in that category. The old icon is 64px. Another question is why KDialog --yesno uses the old style icon. They should both be using the same icon. Attached screenshot shows both Curiouser and curiouser
Icons are deliberately different (lineart) when they're set to be smaller The icon loading part is working fine.
quick dump from IRC [13:45] <sitter> Sho_, notmart: from a the casual investigation I've done I think we can solve this from a code POV by figuring out why QMB requests s a smaller size than kdialog and align the two (I think we need a qstyle hint in plasma-integration for that) [13:46] <sitter> as for the icon itself, Riddell, I think the theme config itself is wrong [13:46] <sitter> status/22 sets [13:46] <sitter> MinSize=22 [13:46] <sitter> MaxSize=32 [13:46] <sitter> status/64 sets [13:46] <sitter> MinSize=22 [13:46] <sitter> MaxSize=256 [13:47] <sitter> so the two overlap between 22 and 32px [13:48] <sitter> which from a casual glance is not the case for any of the other contexts, supposedly status/22 should scale 22-24 and status/64 should scale 32-256
This was fixed a while back.
Changing status according to comment #3.