Make a Signing Key. Make a test key. Sign the test key. Revoke the signature. Import everything in Kleopatra. Go look at User IDs and Certifications on the Test Key. The revocation appears as just another certification. I have an example. The following keyblock is weird. It certifies keys with a _subkey_ instead of the primary key. You can debate whether or not this is standard-acceptable =) But Test Key Two has a revoked signature from Test Signing Key, and illustrates the problem, and avoids you having to gen a bunch of keys to reproduce. Reproducible: Always Steps to Reproduce: See Details Actual Results: Revocation appears as a certification Expected Results: Revocation should be indicated clearly. IMO, the best way to display a revocation is NOT by showing both the certification and the revocation (which is the way gpg and SKS do it) - it's too easy to not notice the revocation. Instead, I would argue for collapsing them into a single line that is struck through and indicated to be revoked. -----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK----- mQINBFaRf78BEACTpudw1k3rt6/z/SGJNDNh8sXSC2s46MBtA33O6fd9F5Dz98Ys PHWlds+ixFRuAidozGJkYqU2wXvmnGIPHT5UM0/L5ARKbgbX77ca+Oxt1ClpQbXY H+XedX+uw9mSgD3+BX68Vylp7tIIjNmWgB+k72He6F0Vw2h/NOYd5TyV+aiAIZnc LTwESExBUXDMbViVl1fJglfTmOTzOgCPjCOUrqHiLAeQ/POy2YyvMsJKZkWzf11p PbBidKl5u3YSc2ooTlUEFGrO42R0/IVhjetbAWwqhqNyOVlO9pg3kzz4B42nins2 jcPk1+pG1SCpMEw+3WMrIaVmD/cKMv6hfLj3O5uOdOVgfx9wfp/+f9lu4kEcf3yB rWV0eRuCbpuyf6v+d5+oAF4vxPDmdFFiL8Bw2pKj+fq6BAsrtluLFM00T6V7Cuj7 lwpThRIuQ/8iGuSqYGn8zDQKZS4v/5IS8k8RCvK22Y7w/DwXRrlIl/nVwnasAcLK WAlCJPvvB/RZI6tvNQhIIFE9R8Gzl1jjM1AilmkEfxxpkmHBGhtslOgWq5KLr68b dRsBipqYaG0+5jUp8STS28h1hbIb7fIJ2EajCIGhc9mcwIvivU/v19tcd678fjpF qon65yVd7P49P3hUl4aDvr3JSaTWCcUu7no5BDXZRQDCxzJqOmHbTXnkkwARAQAB tBBUZXN0IFNpZ25pbmcgS2V5iQI4BBMBAgAiBQJWkX+/AhsDBgsJCAcDAgYVCAIJ CgsEFgIDAQIeAQIXgAAKCRAjVwBFdpcNSns4D/4i/Dpa8AnefSvxzeyqLkJBVreg gB8BHp1WknehBEi0fAxDfKxOkgt7uqzDSIy8QFX8bYFUqfKLdZu0veuCjOoZwRDh v8BNVan3XkTBlQp/HeuwlpFbbj8+gkOzC/aQdvL6bdYAWbvNsH0kxgCO+c5Bn0rC Y6y3nSd0Np9tXuBJaeCLQCO9sJIkTH5/DB58Vw349ib5JbxAWVa5Bit5GpOr29sh lR9VOBSkh2/I/uXyT6s4EJbyuVfuIEuex3MY66Ls6rea0bnWZDUIA4c+pq/SbZUc iM/yYx7Sdop1MG09vKQRUNlRwCt5tWfhHvBIDvXJgxvoyw1aOs5Xxxr5FXcT4WQs 3iJNh5zHxmlxjHtjYUxTj438s+QX+/O+iK0bw5e0oql69kCqIT6be4BpWf7aqwhL HAm27KDxcjTQBZQdzTFo9+pGcujjZg+Q8jxsYqZbR9ZnI6++3y7TVt9/OucD6EmM c+ixiRSzdrhY+QXCgncuJD+RGUhURDNfCdLXFOKFPdiglWzv8PUIYuQofyqV9Eea fH7Jwe7+JUONU6g/EScMXpsoFnvYdSeoxlBesUznwegHkAq9S9cWOSyfgwARH5Bf JUf8egfrNTJM4TpUfVNCyB03WAP54ulSW74fbRkoVq2sWhSkS5ZS1YCl6Qc77H5y MtcB7mXxkDhRxl74ULkCDQRWkYnAARAAskbvbwfYnIk+1M8N4oyAjU4W6x2sLheQ I/7ZH1tJMwnFD3Dxq7qMRmiILZ9HoJ6sY7VIUuyX2U08vojs3uy3hNabZdqdeg25 R6Hk6yOR0L3urSq6YWZ00qpdxhVfc8XGiT2LphgKxm8/mOXiabMyMm98d8kGDCv+ bTwAPF3v5GRzN2bs5prrjMoufH/lqQaFvgNRM+WnqaoXPSlcQSUdvkfdxIPTSoV0 9M/OwfmMkZMSGhKkYooNnfx7UfqPTuQP3expGLl9XbtM1udPxJl6WnO3hvlERMC6 SRWwsHBqnYQGF2CrgAMvSqRbeLXiPH+mrIpGDq6+CaGnFU6yR2XT2uvkqhEXkGxW zFzLcVf6gu4rVE4H1KYG6CTLXKWtp+2X5a8j3V/iUpMSgozqpztoiQcMsaxoK/l7 gvKFMRyHrNDYrRNmk/7TO4F7GWPpNY0OOjqYjDyQE9E7RIDILcxqwdc6RyPRqiZe oFVXEeJHd9V6QiCJmQUj49PQ68Y6G09SnPdeZ2OnKLwPiEcVuRztJAZ0K6/4gpud zbtYxHMAs4FVkmiwRwr776nu2s85jwkoxP306TylWRv5Xa/e2ZNvZkxVgm9oJrTX bn/B6zM2Epkus348I/nCc61cZJH37byQzoj4GfmdVyvFX93+WHyoo7ph8aipr/TW oX85YFhhHucAEQEAAYkEPgQYAQIACQUCVpGJwAIbAwIpCRAjVwBFdpcNSsFdIAQZ AQIABgUCVpGJwAAKCRB1uAUjWwI13xnIEACPkaRoitPbJZ+D6lGi7f9MwzhTbpCP rKejARmWd7tyscZVFi9k5uId5crc+5+yK/oYVX4hQ2I8vAKdx1aXVloqhryBqtDC iJihPE9b7cTdQfYv87LXM2N1/0mRI8xyrFlDwq4IlxASsFd16u45Kb0FODmXIqLE UQ+QNIBWsHBPoOgHdyfRVIV52yJUBo4NhwQHZB45CYJ30tCQzK0AGYZp1T/fbt51 NHVhD+q7ngfHICBGASDlVG0yZxDkBUIxQ/dO/hA7Js1awLdWQo43+DOk6+st2jyw dBb1DAmxOlNUpXeoyLKgfJDbUgT5wvLJe4ldyENzCQpq4+T91FoULsXrXTeVSFIP 4K1RDtvh1uFDz8R10poukVw9xX1MRKHmfq8mLzFBpeQSXfcdxrtCmp+emgtxdSmA /QZ3FBsEKZhDu4hgAjyady8xjWO21jyVZb7RRHTKPkTv56dBdIH0Y68+1FZrSyG9 PCEL3FT9vIYNLCCQ/dTxGznzN7zf2nYeoayZ3SJr0Wkg49+NbOHm/iSRFI6LJnzF ghHoAMBZ2djR3IH992htViUpxUaKGnNlbVe894xhG8qGUnvI8JC4j7kXN+RgtgP1 CADbPcIvUK9sxOxONSzNkoOBLG2PjGNF0XANMZfdOFgjv1CA9lSMdpkJIo8kAPqx pkSvLVXS+HdUygOuD/9mNBh9ifbUgdpirxv6wb1oYl51M56ErWcPi+Fcg5BdZkG7 4sIy/9QDnCAtRiRaqUv2w9EvZImQAOin16HCt9mGFClqjmgrYKXIeoFPZ0T0u2QX APKEFpStFeM4rWjAuOAF8SHdy/jGzB6RyleBEmUXP3sPOSOC2qQcJbFeh0fjprP6 A3a1yvlfKA6qc+ImjisclWL1lSjj91dhhl5EX/bSDlE3Ovamy8l286kWFn0nZsBk dnM+C56Y0rwNs8vbGQNDqasDhPWVp0dENPviyTcuDR4yC2/buBSYsRc2boSiDYML y5MhsttLiOVls0yWep+BZoGSDtrwgFnw8zrWkk/Bv5JimMQZKyc5qm6f83qNG5JY +IezQTZSMXXSvgTGFkhH6NeIbIjABbgebC560sIGwbwTQkIxTuMCQ2Y4SRjbwDGV AQT6WzHeGDBfuV2rFz3vEEGhO0S2e4rUMUfh5CI1kMPkwPGb6KcnQJGSHf1eZFEz xLKJDCEQQJ9lqPped1+8XkKk+O2GiIH/9b/ATP4c8JeD2zAtwf7N5aia+sIxCoj5 JCtAK8lxuQ1ADBn3goaFoktiPPwxtLaUfRjO5q00Opc9K0ZXTUQpnN2aPyRkFTTP FpOF4abN7uFG+RKETCdJZEOlG7JyREEFklp5PidWuAFb3xy4cJGAtVUVy9uc0pkB DQRWkYqSAQgA80ZsWQslBife2ekQ0dvLA0aCVrufI1mz04zFBPBuJ7gugW5PYXYj lKwOJgyhRbVdI0gvhcLCLg5EKcOickfMTN3kDJ56oTcN0TfgK4CVH4RDk4ujh0tH Lq4L/ooo8l+DGnVKU57pKNcPkzmzlFVKxayTJ8DPB4nZJrzUxrGHWexCGP4MM5r7 9GKfi2sBLUjY0s4IrjF01rzwO2IKwioFMhMGCd8e63emeIKjkS7y/yyen0jfyIA7 ARZtpJq7omOFBN4wwWcKjt8RLxWt9LG+WHPI8yApGiSAvaxhaYyqlE73ILdoaPL/ 4sF/4TFLOfRRm50QqC8gHWS9EyVuvVP8ewARAQABtAhUZXN0IEtleYkBOQQTAQgA IwUCVpGKkgIbAwcLCQgHAwIBBhUIAgkKCwQWAgMBAh4BAheAAAoJEPAuX/13m41A oPIIAKG0e2+LUmXLZVUUv4uBL06FtJYnYB4U+sv4VHAoxGokR7I5Q3qpHwfUacF4 MASUCFQn0NuYGXC+LWysUcTeAUwlvXWJMfptzrVsP/pc7pvSLWI7xIWyRry8Au/O fzmZqZHxMYFwcDpV5A9hAax1j65IJBP2mBweBXoGXKdy5uqSNlwlIkQpYcMHUVRE 68JCYBDTwNQO0zHgflZXUan7PGTQgGXuyOgNZ/8AgPNlik26cPOYvcD8x/6t/91l FdRC9iJCCC9c3DMQoYXfiQV5cDEsDZwc+iG89M7ol9AvGDejM8oeNVKf4EOttosM p7CuEGG/0j/ck9H5ZuxPy5A374uJAhwEEAECAAYFAlaRitMACgkQdbgFI1sCNd/i cw//Zkv9rZ+R5syE6t509GlJTamnA4PRQJWY8PJE4aesTCPD33gxeNeA9O1HAAKc Ni1MFD3rIkETWmNs8O7Z+SZb8CjCdd27svYJVU5yEmjBtOOWSk4LlLNm4p5r8ouj 9o6NsnoFcnkN+/f3cnxaR+wO9Kqt+0ueSJH3MwXFMzY6ef3P/IgnLnJ/d0pwcOa2 L+utN6xez51YzAE+h0ldPqqszSU0eT5EFGIEJW/rCI8/GMSKLjR2jmBjOcMWcfmY 12/WTOwVMNn82YJf3rO9STdBYtB7m9FfpHc45y53DTPx5t0maKQ5ETHlVhZebiH0 6tasnork28D0JsdEDZ2hsZImpclkLURlB6ySMZyhwUJecRHe6LqiAOieV1r1ayFU TYiCqfzLLO0eKcFznHTukWfeJ/17s8hDPxO2XD3sWYXRvVY6UV5NATS2L3pDtz/M +dcO0+ppwuWrk1GLtLxyz7+uJaIWJMuwc1MfaqAt4cOo/96Qz7x6hhpKZbCEamHA vByTpaTEllQUdKrVhfFiTo+Xffj8GU2lSDS1PusMj24z1mft1XajBZQzKOub5/kJ acpdAPqt9r8bQiW8Ubi1+GDSeqK8r1rvgDYtSidEPS+L+l1UmOCvlmpD6dKHjKlJ ai32Y3R0177PRgi5SQDuENs6Kj8RU+/y3BDhahUugxQz1U+5AQ0EVpGKkgEIAK5R i1LjIamSJ/bHVp/a4UihBNvAPrda0MsyDw8vIuQd958BDzcgA673rDxf7LW2FYP1 TWdiUkbBwvN4c7EZGh/ujJ4Y9fokv6vNdRE6+gW6TiMe2GoY5cBt3xnbMWQ0TPF0 5XWCiMc2Mft25NQvNu//B2nbPA+o9ju2w9s+qQVEcM7LVvsDLvpGw4ka40dMU0gB G5azOx//s24W7dBaujpdANclQdWVXkf1qJbhyWhGhMfND1cAmd5RajR/dToxz7XS CvzLEdNupp7rWxhEesZMnSlVj500pkfB+MpAA8BPaAFBBJjtgx55UG8AkpVLNB/n ugsw95S1T3f9NE1RxYEAEQEAAYkBHwQYAQgACQUCVpGKkgIbDAAKCRDwLl/9d5uN QPnqCADdegwXY8EhZrUa+hLR3ZNVkG3y5tSagpBzYcWvZR2xYHFdA68VZEl9WeS7 I0SvL7ONhpxvGPOkU9Yrr8IjQXYhTHUkezF3gSv+0qEFjGT2GsSWX5+/93KTYSBM 4Lan7Cn4epwhzWI8Xh+vH394mstDwnuJC/rX7ahC2OaWFTM9N1S3Qi4FapHgJ03Z iN60AwYCx4//PzrAAeSB4I3suHSj9d0T3HLdGZ2SehDtmU4V/EOASSHAloljRDeU C848RpJOaz1lzjFdZCjXZGYp5mL3L9iUsjwbxDHZtYdjGowgvFCSxoTa9aEZl/uq 9HXh+NzvR2mXWdcLGnRVo0b/vZn1mQENBFaRjAoBCADl+XZW+pRKSjbFTf3H5P/H hLuieO1RT9POreH4rVQ+XKtvgpIBBj02gzSrRM/GtNX6aJQweNjH7Re4fUhQbIgh ySJ+S07zXkf4lRBpa3IM35kBn93TbwSuq1VPq2yI1KUitwrXIgSY/YDK54wMA+3m 2VD/cQ2kgIQ1xAyoDE3LRGw1KT2SBOtpVdcMLw+PL/m6HRvhcyY8CCwrGfvkljJn sVDHZPsAkL61WWkfGddVMJkTJwDs2MnbhbVDGnL2jPp79tbb3SBkfHPZE3oG5cVb x3mFfryGzhF/qwpTZ+K3Epi80QvqAhwQ4bIHTeehRS1HY7QhcNRJWzDPs0FrDP1N ABEBAAG0DFRlc3QgS2V5IFR3b4kCHwQwAQgACQUCVpGMhgIdAAAKCRB1uAUjWwI1 3zl2D/4n+qIS2v/95vcDgAcKIWpmzQry2TAla1veI6fbjamZnBIkOQ0OCtga/AnC IoL2dieJaw66BjHiHsxvN0k3ZhZeg2fupw+itTWJicWY1JweU3egDGMCBz4bpz5d FjvMPN7Bn/CjXgnP924+/8W+5/qljwoyQ6NgUSYf7It0bkdjZphpfaIrbzQmDZK5 uYv/8Z7J9Yu9KlTXtgNdGxMaq9kWbMIZiyKj+quElLe4X6eLWrFHijv/AjNT4sQr txJ7FmcAzGZitCLDtdL2FurZd4eBVGFmpO9DSQZHhrMNPasFL7S7Kqcp57Fg7ZY6 fz3ptE1X1wRRqTCSKSrNMP+9ZQQhSIkM/HCCw/ljyaIX9cff1CaCynQZnISU1tAN kc2GJ9y7RxKqYs91pgDeIHfhOc0qphrv6C3ejYZHEyTgdIuUIOAtUPPTaBXgA0I6 R+qLD9rUga34Bvaa4f417V+ZViiAfWLgU1/9KejVEKNzy4CwJzv0A8sYw2jLamAG frPHhOSLyPh/k1yb72GhsPcJ7QWkZubdnSzZEE0aqKMwoo8ITeH2YjSnQCM0AXMs DwKFZiTCzylCygQsgssJNtmiCUxsa/oWpEDA4KhOsHYzrcvmTTJZ0IhMqCUiDbQb 6W6ckxJdqbmTi/Ug50FL2Ze5tkQ7owil9B9M2eaYIrDj/zjUq4kBOQQTAQgAIwUC VpGMCgIbAwcLCQgHAwIBBhUIAgkKCwQWAgMBAh4BAheAAAoJEKWjt6McVEax08wI AKLjvarnAj+jt6pEkOktxKw0g+a/6aazrSPv6D0BgmU92WI8/3DZENqShuLk7+Kl mmKGU9k/QfAKXQG674qMlgfqo6u73M6z1FmcRoxMvAR/0UOkjn6PkMcXNn0HmweT h9iNhGb4+hjU+js2y7fJYZxSCg0cRFfkzRtGQ3onUEOotu3K5z3CLget+NTqNghE KvGAFKOjpPOUpXeZgpqDEuP3WMf1nUJ9xlHJTfE3RBRU85CnPFF/HwlSa2KPjviC zcO0QqjXYi/PyhcejchABqCV+ce6oJ7Qp1RvfgN70cB2HnIVt93MX937HqLdTX/a 7GmDsW1j0uo6bM6NCHSptwWJAhwEEAECAAYFAlaRjDcACgkQdbgFI1sCNd+N6w/9 F6jVVoGsrUBuEcrRJR0O1FIZWHgpkf/dJWM2L2H2WFjEvJNZMDO0PQGSEpMcvF3r 0tYnBz3X+/4wi71gOnJ7bUuksaz1auXXbuK2p3JmnaVDjVo2/B3i7zzpSm+VL58u C8eBaRC6LHCOHEHUgPmh49wV6/pRLU7mbs9od3Ep2SN/Da411ImIqmCwstQX71y/ VFCkLWMJhzLiD/7vpHlgvFQOqE3h/NaqudnR+BzX0O/BRgUL3Dg4cdDdx5gfIS3e LTDvA6lTT+5NLBZNy7E8fudS7HNEHCRkWnvXC3NjylurHlOs7bzgEoVnFIjdfhaJ 214sVKsstAmWHfQ5iR82tzlYn2vb596uNxN/kBpshNpBh7orrVshg0vhC6aPQKmr IBrzAQ9ZDTMHuZQ2pH1D+LXfGTiY3IHFi/tkfrMNnDcsrFhOQd446e6xiZt7Ci2J B0AO5nMup0h7FTnA5MpSBoNiNwPOke3c9k9+q0nzRuw3VYLPhbk6HGL2ovTdvKuY pOqiM4zzsw/xP7YXcBFcI27Y6z/bc5cxORE2juCWjcBzlaDR4JC5YyfVOXhwkQDz 9jXNO34wrHPlC7SVggexwphzocqTkP5hYyrhUPb9mBrE6e5Vcxs0/Mixfu/UwZeV bvFVRhaS19P4MsajuDsw269GiOyjCQ3KZPhFMI1Wrf65AQ0EVpGMCgEIAMBMUK94 zpsTxymQVRE4ttFdJGGemiTEKK5PjrCaymZPGqHtiBYGdt0WtlNnIWOUzLoObFFc +Yn7UQme+O0Qz73EFhamYIUhRZhgS7jneADod/2XiIs0E76svX1Zb2Gm6EowJq4k iLGcvIkdpbaVUwbdTfU+ZUeBJVHvq62gsiZS/dU52ZK8o1e4ObgAUZmARP6fdKV6 KkXGhma7dKWDDPABaRJiWU0HdwUgHG8d3YqIPrc2lbkwCo7u3s7c193DgCujDkp+ CsxzF44hd/BNq5vNzg8tI/0cRuT0woTFaSvKty+DhI2thnM55ccxw4JSRyqHWCGr pew8lbvkBFzF18cAEQEAAYkBHwQYAQgACQUCVpGMCgIbDAAKCRClo7ejHFRGscbk B/0TEEZexfnbvtjQ5biKfuwnv5xG6vTSI+sIa9W0HSOGl2q0zlWgI+tV/Pr00PpN 5/axNMfMrHYyztSCMOW7ZaOpXLiF7dNkgLW2YzHzhA9dQsLXprvs1aFNwC540R18 KX190+lzQHCkjONS7eGhLCM7G156Xc11SABbTcqPpYLbsnNhFERe3BkzVUsuclAB QshA/DG61wkp6axuTYMCrM3nKPjKn3peibc7gAaBklN5xf9/H2lBEKQ8RncUAH77 hV4cfGI3+aSGNkBQN7na1vZK8qO0uZXQN30SpHUkoRokOBtys/7u2+XpnhsdkqZS fa4oRnT6D2bGbbXdehs6T3iZ =plWJ -----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
Well the Info is shown if you know your RFC's ;-) https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc4880#section-5.2.1 Clearly indicates that the "Status" kleopatra shows as "class 48" means that it is a signature of type: 0x30: Certification revocation signature This was a joke :-). Kleopatra users should not have to know the signature types defined in the RFC. So confirmed as a bug. This dialog needs an overhaul. Only the identity confirming signatures should be shown. And revocation needs to be clearer indicated. I'm not sure that removing them would be the best. I rather think we could use the Status Column for that. Color it in Green normally and if it was revoked color it in red and add a tooltip "This Certification was revoked on <timestamp>"