Bug 354759 - Amarok freezes while meta data changes are applied
Summary: Amarok freezes while meta data changes are applied
Status: RESOLVED WORKSFORME
Alias: None
Product: amarok
Classification: Applications
Component: Metadata Editing and Reading (other bugs)
Version First Reported In: 2.8.0
Platform: Fedora RPMs Linux
: NOR major
Target Milestone: 2.9
Assignee: Amarok Bugs
URL:
Keywords:
Depends on:
Blocks:
 
Reported: 2015-11-02 22:38 UTC by sedrubal
Modified: 2022-11-18 05:17 UTC (History)
3 users (show)

See Also:
Latest Commit:
Version Fixed/Implemented In:
Sentry Crash Report:


Attachments

Note You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.
Description sedrubal 2015-11-02 22:38:16 UTC
It seems that some actions are not separated from the view:
E.g. changing meta data (of multiple tracks) will make the view not to react on inputs.

Reproducible: Always

Steps to Reproduce:
1. mark multiple tracks in you collection and right click > "Edit Track Details"
2. change something
3. hit "Save & Close"

Actual Results:  
the view freezes but thankfully the music continues playing ;)

Expected Results:  
I want to use the view while the changes are applied in the background
Comment 1 Myriam Schweingruber 2015-11-03 13:06:58 UTC
If there is a freeze we would need at least an output of the konsole when this happens, and it matters a lot if the tracks you write to are local or remote, or on a different file system...

Please start Amarok with

amarok -d --nofork and paste the portion of output when the freeze happens
Comment 2 sedrubal 2015-11-03 14:14:51 UTC
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... 
amarok: BEGIN: virtual TagDialog::~TagDialog() 
amarok: END__: virtual TagDialog::~TagDialog() [Took: 0s] 
Calling appendChild() on a null node does nothing.

It freezes during: amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... (But yesterday it took much longer for the same actions; I don't know why...)
Comment 3 Myriam Schweingruber 2015-11-03 16:48:43 UTC
How many files do you change at the same time?
Comment 4 sedrubal 2015-11-03 16:57:58 UTC
Each "amarok: [TagDialog] File info changed.... " line is one file.
Comment 5 Myriam Schweingruber 2015-11-03 19:19:30 UTC
Ernm, so I am supposed to count those lines? it also doesn't tell how many ID3 tags you are changing at the same time...

FWIW: Amarok was never meant to be a mass tagging software, there are better tools out there to tag a collection. We added tagging only so you could fill in the occasional missing tag. Please us kid3 or any other mass tagger if you need to tag a whole collection
Comment 6 sedrubal 2015-11-03 22:17:14 UTC
You can use 'wc' :P It's wayne how many files I change, the more the longer amarok freezes. It's also completely unimportant how many tags I change.

I think that amarok needs longer for this action when it run for a long time (today it's working better than yesterday...).

Mh I think Amarok should handle this...
Comment 7 Myriam Schweingruber 2015-11-04 01:21:47 UTC
Well, if you think Amarok should be a jack of all trades, please give a hand in coding and maintaining the code. This is a lot of work, btw, so I think the developers had and still have legitimate reasons not to make Amarok a mass tagger. There are standalone apps that do this much faster.
Comment 8 Rick Timmis 2015-12-03 21:11:54 UTC
Whilst testing this on Amarok Version 2.5.0 on Kubuntu LTS 12.04 I could not get this fault to reproduce.
Comment 9 Justin Zobel 2022-10-19 02:59:54 UTC
Thank you for reporting this bug in KDE software. As it has been a while since this issue was reported, can we please ask you to see if you can reproduce the issue with a recent software version?

If you can reproduce the issue, please change the status to "CONFIRMED" when replying. Thank you!
Comment 10 Bug Janitor Service 2022-11-03 05:06:46 UTC
Dear Bug Submitter,

This bug has been in NEEDSINFO status with no change for at least
15 days. Please provide the requested information as soon as
possible and set the bug status as REPORTED. Due to regular bug
tracker maintenance, if the bug is still in NEEDSINFO status with
no change in 30 days the bug will be closed as RESOLVED > WORKSFORME
due to lack of needed information.

For more information about our bug triaging procedures please read the
wiki located here:
https://community.kde.org/Guidelines_and_HOWTOs/Bug_triaging

If you have already provided the requested information, please
mark the bug as REPORTED so that the KDE team knows that the bug is
ready to be confirmed.

Thank you for helping us make KDE software even better for everyone!
Comment 11 Bug Janitor Service 2022-11-18 05:17:01 UTC
This bug has been in NEEDSINFO status with no change for at least
30 days. The bug is now closed as RESOLVED > WORKSFORME
due to lack of needed information.

For more information about our bug triaging procedures please read the
wiki located here:
https://community.kde.org/Guidelines_and_HOWTOs/Bug_triaging

Thank you for helping us make KDE software even better for everyone!