| Summary: | Auto-hiding panel sometimes moves to middle of the screen when being viewed | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Product: | [Unmaintained] plasma4 | Reporter: | Dmitri <dkour> |
| Component: | panel | Assignee: | Plasma Bugs List <plasma-bugs> |
| Status: | RESOLVED WORKSFORME | ||
| Severity: | normal | CC: | 13.finn, 1i5t5.duncan, antonio.toma, bugs.kde.org.id324, cookie170, guido-kdebugs, heri+kde, hinsch.martin, k_the_first, leandrosansilva, lord.awikatchikaen, malkavian666, next_ghost, pngochai, rauchwolke, rpuskas, scp.stjohn, thijs22nospam, wrar |
| Priority: | NOR | ||
| Version: | 4.8.3 | ||
| Target Milestone: | --- | ||
| Platform: | Fedora RPMs | ||
| OS: | Linux | ||
| Latest Commit: | Version Fixed In: | 4.9.1 | |
| Sentry Crash Report: | |||
| Attachments: |
Screenshot showing bad panel position
Proper panel behavior Improper Panel Behavior Config file causing the problem Diff to the good config file |
||
This might be related to my bug #271532, regression between 4.6.1 and 4.6.2, still present in 4.6.3: https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=271532 After some investigation I have been able to reproduce this bug 100% of the time. When there is a window near the top of the screen, the panel is unable to fit in the space between the top of the screen and the top of the focused window. In this case the panel jumps down and snaps to the bottom of the window; or as far down as necessary so that it doesn't overlap any windows. If the focused window is maximized, the panel can't fit anywhere and stays at the top of the screen. I'll add some attachements showing the difference between normal and improper panel behavior. Created attachment 59749 [details]
Proper panel behavior
Panel behaves correctly when it has enough between top of screen and nearest window.
Created attachment 59750 [details]
Improper Panel Behavior
Panel jumps to window button once there is not enough space for it to fit between top of screen and top of window.
A temporary work-around to this issue can be done by creating a special window rule: Window Class: Plasma Window Role: Dock(panel) Geometry Option: Placement = Force: No Placement It seems that the window placement functionality is what's trying to move the plasma panel out of the way? It also happens with me. I have two panels which are auto-hidden: one on top of the screen and other in the bottom-left. To reproduce this bug, I resize a window and put keep a free space in it's border. When I put the mouse on the top of the screen, the panel isn't there, but under that window. Even when I maximize the window, the panel continues there. To restore the panel to it's original place, I put the mouse it (with the maximized window) and, on mouse out, it go back to the top. It sometime also happens with lateral panels, but I couldn't reproduce right now. It also happens with me. I have two panels which are auto-hidden: one on top of the screen and other in the bottom-left. To reproduce this bug, I resize a window and put keep a free space in it's border. When I put the mouse on the top of the screen, the panel isn't there, but under that window. Even when I maximize the window, the panel continues there. To restore the panel to it's original place, I put the mouse it (with the maximized window) and, on mouse out, it go back to the top. It sometime also happens with lateral panels, but I couldn't reproduce right now. I have had this issue on both Kubuntu 10.04 and now with Debian unstable running KDE 4.6.5. I only run one panel at the top of the screen with autohide on. If I have multiple windows open on one desktop it can sometimes be a little difficult to figure out which window the panel has decided to move below, leaving me to use alt+F1 to get it to show itself. I experiencing the same problem on my desktop computer but not on my laptop. turning composition on or off makes no difference. sorry both are running the same KDE version 4.6.5-2 from Debian but have different videocards the Desktop has a 4 year old nvidia the laptop an 1 year amd both are run on the proprietary drivers Same here with KDE 4.6.5 (Debian testing) Bug seems to be same as 277248 (URL: https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=277248) found solution for me (recreate plasmaconfiguration (description: https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=277248#c7 )) . Same with kubuntu 11.04, kde 4.7.2, vertical auto-hide panel (left border) *** Bug 277248 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. *** *** Bug 271155 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. *** There seem to be a bunch of these reports. What they have in common: 1) Non-consistency 2) Autohide 3) It's about panels that are not on the bottom of the screen 4) Introduced somewhere during 4.6, but still there 5) Many seem to have multi monitors 6) Often triggered by a window touching the relevant screen edge Possibly, this bug is related to 281029, where the wandering happens for non-autohide panels after some kind of restart. Maybe, but this is far fetched, it is even related to the wandering cashew (bug 287809) with as a meta-bug: Plasma cannot count. (In reply to comment #16) > There seem to be a bunch of these reports. What they have in common: > 1) Non-consistency > 2) Autohide Happened to me for both types. > 3) It's about panels that are not on the bottom of the screen Confirming - never happened to me for a bottom aligned panel. > 4) Introduced somewhere during 4.6, but still there > 5) Many seem to have multi monitors I dont. > 6) Often triggered by a window touching the relevant screen edge For me it has something to do with Yakuake. When Yakuake is open and plasma restarts (e.g. due to a crash), the panel will be at the bottom of the Yakuake window. Same happens on another machine with an auto-hide panel that moves there even without a prior plasma crash. still present in kde 4.8.1 *** This bug has been confirmed by popular vote. *** This happened to me on both Gentoo and Archlinux, but recently it does not happen in Archlinux anymore. I had the same problem on one machine. The others had the same installation but not this problem. Although widgets and the panel were locked it would jump to the middle or lower part of the screen if an open window was moved to the top of the screen. It appears to have been resolved by increasing the height of the panel slightly in panel settings. Persists in KDE 4.8.3. I reported on 04-29-12 that I had this problem on only one of my computers - all running the same installation of Fedora 16 and the latest KDE 4. I was able to fix it by increasing the height of the panel slightly. After replacing a monitor and increasing the screen resolution on yet another machine the same problem appeared. Again, I was able to resolve it by increasing the panel height. It would seem that this bug is related to screen resolution and panel height and is temporarily resolved by increasing the panel height. For me deleting "~/.kde/share/config/plasma-desktoprc" helps then i log in an set the panel to auto hide again ervery other plasma config (plasmoids and so on) stayed the same. (In reply to comment #24) > For me deleting "~/.kde/share/config/plasma-desktoprc" helps then i log in > an set the panel to auto hide again ervery other plasma config (plasmoids > and so on) stayed the same. Confirming this. Logout, Login as root on the console, killall -u $myuser, delete the file, logout root and login graphically and the issue appears to be fixed. (In reply to comment #25) > (In reply to comment #24) > > For me deleting "~/.kde/share/config/plasma-desktoprc" helps then i log in > > an set the panel to auto hide again ervery other plasma config (plasmoids > > and so on) stayed the same. > Confirming this Thanks, both of you. That should get us much closer. Could someone who still has the old plasma-desktoprc file please carefully copy it elsewhere, then delete the ~/.kde/share/config/ copy of it and confirm that the problem is fixed on relogin? A copy of the new version or a diff between the bad and the good one might be useful as well. We have two reports that this file is the problem, so if we had a copy of the triggering version and either a good version or the diff between them, that should pretty well nail the culprit lines, and hopefully allow a good code-fix. It would also allow anyone else with the problem to verify whether they had the bad lines and try deleting just them if so. It's always possible there's more than one trigger for the problem, so if we get a culprit line or set of lines and someone with the problem doesn't have that set, we know there's another problem with the same symptoms to investigate. (I'm just a user, but CCed as I had a related problem at one point, see comment #1 and bug # 271532.) Duncan Please, people, don't forget to update the versions Created attachment 71291 [details]
Config file causing the problem
This is the offending file from my system. When I've moved it from KDE's config directory and set panel to autohide again, the problem didn't reappear after next relogin.
Created attachment 71292 [details]
Diff to the good config file
Here's a diff of the offending file to freshly generated config file after all settings were applied by hand.
The most immediate "jump-out" from looking at that config file and diff, is that plasma stores information per panel size. That aligns nicely with the reports of people fixing the problem by changing the panel size slightly, since that would create a new section (assuming they hadn't used that size before) in the config, without the issue. Another takeaway is that there's a bit of config stored for every size and orientation you've had each panel in. If you've moved it around and resized it, trying to figure out the best size and orientation, that means you have a whole list of settings for various orientations and sizes that aren't being used at the current time, and can probably be deleted, thus simplifying the file quite a bit. That's why the diff has so many more deleted lines than changed/added, because the new config doesn't have all those extra size and location settings. But as a result, there's way more lines in the diff than I had hoped, and I've not yet noticed a possible culprit for this bug, yet. But I've not looked too hard yet, just noticed those two things jumping out at me right away... One more thing to note, looking at my own copy of that file: Most of the settings in that file appear to be pretty minor, dialog sizes, panel autohide settings, etc. But it also appears to store (or to have stored in the past, perhaps) the krunner plugin settings, if you've changed them from the default, say disabling some of them, that appears to be stored in that file, so expect all the krunner plugins to be enabled (or whatever the default is, I'd guess all enabled) again, if you delete the file. But that part shouldn't be related and it isn't in the bad file posted, so if you have changed them and want to keep that, it should be safe to leave at least those krunner and plugin settings in the file, or copy them to the new one once it's recreated. *** Bug 271532 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. *** *** Bug 297189 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. *** Do you still need broken configs? Git commit 59b1e4e4387a9194125bfac35a23ad885c9c24e6 by Rolf Eike Beer. Committed on 16/07/2012 at 18:27. Pushed by dakon into branch 'KDE/4.9'. fix wrong panel positioning, especially when more than one monitor is present This workaround was found by Kai Dombrowe. This is likely just papering over a deeper issue, but for the time being this just makes the panel work. Related: bug 283974, bug 281029 REVIEW:105596 FIXED-IN:4.9.1 M +2 -0 plasma/desktop/shell/panelview.cpp http://commits.kde.org/kde-workspace/59b1e4e4387a9194125bfac35a23ad885c9c24e6 I've had an issue (this may be it) where my top plasma panel would move down about 25 pixels, leaving a gap at the top. I personally this has something to do with dual monitors and the plasma "search and launch" widget. My work around for solving this is mkdir $HOME/.kde/share/config/plasma-desktop.bak/ mv $HOME/.kde/share/config/plasma-desktop-screen-1* $HOME/.kde/share/config/plasma-desktop.bak/ I swear I tried so many things and this was the one that nipped it right in the butt for me. I cam across this idea from temporarily solving the problem when I enabled the second monitor (TV), and noticing the "search and launch" widget hanging out at the top. My habit is to always move it and I noticed when I was done using the TV, I restarted X and on login, my panel was at the correct position. I noticed though, for some reason, enabling the TV again would cause my top panel to move on subsequent logins. I ended up putting the following in a startup script and now I no longer have the problem. mv $HOME/.kde/share/config/plasma-desktop-screen-1* $HOME/.kde/share/config/plasma-desktop.bak/ I'm convinced something is wrong with the plasma-desktop-screen files. This may not be a great idea if you're constantly using dual screens or have worked hard on configuring your plasma screens and would like to keep them. Just a possible answer I guess. (In reply to comment #35) > I personally this has something > to do with dual monitors and the plasma "search and launch" widget. I have just one monitor and am experiencing the same problem. Search&Launch is the Alt+F2 thing? My idea was that the Plasma Kidney on the desktop is blocking the space for the panel, but I was not able to verify that somehow. Try increasing the panel height slightly. I have found this permanently resolves the issue. It looks like after upgrading to 4.9.1 this is solved. I say 'it looks like' because I had just increased panel height as SP suggested. Can someone with a clean config confirm? (In reply to comment #38) > It looks like after upgrading to 4.9.1 this is solved. I say 'it looks like' > because I had just increased panel height as SP suggested. Can someone with > a clean config confirm? The sibling bug #281029 was also fixed in 4.9.1, so this seems likely. I can't reproduce this here with KDE 4.9.1, closing I can confirm this bug is fixed. I recently hit it again when I switched screen resolutions. When I upgraded to KDE 4.9.2 a few days later, the bug disappeared without any changes to the config file mentioned above. |
Created attachment 59710 [details] Screenshot showing bad panel position Version: unspecified (using KDE 4.6.2) OS: Linux An auto-hiding panel aligned with the top of the screen will sometimes move from the top to the middle of the screen. The panel still functions after movement, including visual glow effect when mouse is near, and appearing when the mouse moves over it's new position. Switching to a different desktop or starting up a new application will usually restore the panel to the top. Switching back to the other desktop often makes it move again. Behavior seems to be most commonly associated when a kopete window pops up, however I think I've seen it happen for other applications and windows too. Reproducible: Sometimes Steps to Reproduce: Blank desktop/workspace. A new window appears, e.g. a chat window for kopete, or an application is started. User moves mosue to top of screen to interact with panel. Actual Results: Panel suddenly jumps to random y-position on the screen. Expected Results: Panel appears and stays at the top of the screen. Screenshot is attached to show the error more clearly. Note that normally the panel is auto-hidden at the top of the screen.