Bug 13023

Summary: Wrong Disk IDs
Product: [Unmaintained] kscd Reporter: olaf
Component: generalAssignee: Dirk Foersterling <millibyte>
Status: CLOSED FIXED    
Severity: normal    
Priority: NOR    
Version: unspecified   
Target Milestone: ---   
Platform: unspecified   
OS: Other   
Latest Commit: Version Fixed In:
Sentry Crash Report:

Description Olaf Hartig 2000-10-16 13:54:25 UTC 
(*** This bug was imported into bugs.kde.org ***)

Package: kscd
Version: KDE 2.0 RC2

Kscd version 1.3.0 (from KDE2 RC2) often reads different Disk IDs than Kscd 
version 1.2.7 (of KDE 1.1.2).

The following table contains examples:

Kscd-   |
version |   CD1    |    CD2   | ...
--------+-----------------------------------------------------------------
1.2.7   | 54103017 | 4f0c8a16 | 5d11a518 | 0d114022 | c008500f | ed0ac611
1.3.0   | 54102f17 | 4f0c8916 | 5d11a418 | 0d114022 | c008500f | ed0ac511

The Kscd 1.2.7 IDs are the right ones (BTW. Krabber 0.4.4 has the same).
I'm running a standard SuSE 7.0 box but I had these problems with SuSE 6.4 
too (on the same machine).

Ole (olaf@punkbands.de)
Comment 1 Andrew Kuchling 2000-10-19 18:31:25 UTC 
Here's another example (the more test cases the better!):

--amk

Your CDDB submission was rejected for the following reason:
 
Invalid DB submission: disc ID generated from track offsets (2e0da305)
not found in DISCID

...

# xmcd CD database file
# Generated: Thu Oct 19 14:23:37 2000 by KSCD
#
# Track frame offsets:
#       182
#       19527
#       39015
#       132282
#       189270
#
# Disc length: 3493 seconds
#
# Revision: 3
# Submitted via: Kscd 1.3.0
#
DISCID=2e0da205
DTITLE=John Adams / Earbox disc 6
TTITLE0=Tromba Lontana
TTITLE1=Short Ride in a Fast Machine
TTITLE2=Common Tones in Simple Time
TTITLE3=El Dorado / Part I. A Dream of Gold
TTITLE4=El Dorado / Part II. Soledades
EXTD=
EXTT0=
EXTT1=
EXTT2=
EXTT3=
EXTT4=
PLAYORDER=
Comment 2 Dirk Foersterling 2000-10-28 07:19:01 UTC 
Hi

can you please tell me what CD-ROM drive you are using? Can't reproduce
this with several drives here.

  -dirk
  
-- 
                   D i r k   F "o r s t e r l i n g                  
  milliByte@gmx.net  ********  http://www.DeathsDoor.com/milliByte/
                           -------------
                WorkMan - The Civilized CD Player
Comment 3 Dirk Foersterling 2000-11-02 05:56:00 UTC 
There was a mistake in the discid calculation. This has been corrected.

-- 
                   D i r k   F "o r s t e r l i n g                  
  milliByte@gmx.net  ********  http://www.DeathsDoor.com/milliByte/
                           -------------
FATAL! Error writing signa314' mäö#ü433 vkvcv.a4o  4'3  Ã