Bug 60960 - Attachment is dropped when forwarding empty emails
Summary: Attachment is dropped when forwarding empty emails
Status: RESOLVED FIXED
Alias: None
Product: kmail
Classification: Applications
Component: mime (show other bugs)
Version: 1.5.2
Platform: Gentoo Packages Linux
: NOR normal
Target Milestone: ---
Assignee: kdepim bugs
URL:
Keywords:
: 73656 74015 (view as bug list)
Depends on:
Blocks:
 
Reported: 2003-07-09 04:23 UTC by Thomas Bevan
Modified: 2007-09-14 12:17 UTC (History)
1 user (show)

See Also:
Latest Commit:
Version Fixed In:

Attachments
Add an attachment

Note You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.
Description Thomas Bevan 2003-07-09 04:23:50 UTC 
Version:           1.5.2 (using KDE 3.1.2)
Installed from:    Gentoo
Compiler:          gcc version 3.2.3 20030422 (Gentoo Linux 1.4 3.2.3-r1, propolice)
OS:          Linux (i686) release 2.4.20-gentoo-r3

I received photos by email which I wished to forward.
Some emails contained text and others did not.
When I tried to forward those without text, the attachment disappeared.

Included: email source ( address removed )

Received: from tolltech.com.au (smtpgw [203.11.81.70])
	by eel.toll.com.au (8.11.6/8.11.6) with ESMTP id h5TMgDK24824
	for <XXXXX@eel.toll.com.au>; Mon, 30 Jun 2003 08:42:13 +1000 (EST)
Received: from mgscn07.jp-c.ne.jp (localhost [127.0.0.1])
	by tolltech.com.au (8.11.6/8.11.6) with ESMTP id h5TMgBt01642
	for <XXXXX@toll.com.au>; Mon, 30 Jun 2003 08:42:12 +1000 (EST)
X-Authentication-Warning: nursey.toll.com.au: iscan owned process doing -bs
Received: (from root@localhost)
	by mgscn07.jp-c.ne.jp (8.9.2+3.1W/3.7W) id HAA12930
	for <XXXXX@toll.com.au>; Mon, 30 Jun 2003 07:42:06 +0900 (JST)
Message-Id: <200306292242.HAA12930@jp-c.ne.jp>
To: XXXX@toll.com.au
From: XXXX@jp-c.ne.jp
Date: Mon, 30 Jun 2003 07:42:06 +0900
X-Priority: 3
Reply-To: XXXXX@jp-c.ne.jp
Errors-To: XXXXX@jp-c.ne.jp
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: image/jpeg;
  name="03-06-29_18-21.jpg"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Length: 6813
X-UID: 1991
Status: RO
X-Status: O
X-KMail-EncryptionState: N
X-KMail-SignatureState: N

/9j/4AAQSkZJRgABAgAAAQABAAD/2wCEAAgGBgcGBQgHBwcJCQgKDBQNDAsLDBkSEw8UHRofHh0aHBwg
JC4nICIsIxwcKDcpLDAxNDQ0Hyc5PTgyPC4zNDIBCQkJDAsMGA0NGDIhHCEyMjIyMjIyMjIyMjIyMjIy
MjIyMjIyMjIyMjIyMjIyMjIyMjIyMjIyMjIyMjIyMjIyMv/EAaIAAAEFAQEBAQEBAAAAAAAAAAABAgME
BQYHCAkKCwEAAwEBAQEBAQEBAQAAAAAAAAECAwQFBgcICQoLEAACAQMDAgQDBQUEBAAAAX0BAgMABBEF
EiExQQYTUWEHInEUMoGRoQgjQrHBFVLR8CQzYnKCCQoWFxgZGiUmJygpKjQ1Njc4OTpDREVGR0hJSlNU
VVZXWFlaY2RlZmdoaWpzdHV2d3h5eoOEhYaHiImKkpOUlZaXmJmaoqOkpaanqKmqsrO0tba3uLm6wsPE
xcbHyMnK0tPU1dbX2Nna4eLj5OXm5+jp6vHy8/T19vf4+foRAAIBAgQEAwQHBQQEAAECdwABAgMRBAUh
MQYSQVEHYXETIjKBCBRCkaGxwQkjM1LwFWJy0QoWJDThJfEXGBkaJicoKSo1Njc4OTpDREVGR0hJSlNU
VVZXWFlaY2RlZmdoaWpzdHV2d3h5eoKDhIWGh4iJipKTlJWWl5iZmqKjpKWmp6ipqrKztLW2t7i5usLD
xMXGx8jJytLT1NXW19jZ2uLj5OXm5+jp6vLz9PX29/j5+v/AABEIAIAAeAMBIgACEQEDEQH/2gAMAwEA
AhEDEQA/APGtJmiTTr6J42ae427GERYhRncQdw9eeD07Yq5oetLZanZQ311M9jBMpZQOCM88UyC6n0yG
BE1ORYthcQqD8hYdDuHfOCRXQT6h4S1jUjcXlgbWDylDm3+V5XOAWIHAxyeBzxQndaGMrXdzJ8W63YeJ
b+Oe001ba5I+dkJJlb6dP89at+CfA83ii7m895ILWNCHYLtYP2HI56VpSan4ZsntV0rSdshKObiVjlG7
rkdu2cV6FpnjbRpYbRzdwxExl7lymMuBgoOOTk547Cqtzy6fIXPyRsjpfDmkR6BoNrpaMJBAuC4GN5JJ
JI9eaqeMjfr4auW0zzPtCkN+6J37c84x1+la1rOl1bpPHnY43KT3HY1z3iiTV98TaLqUKTKCXtpGA3AE
DIPr8wGD14rdPljoYbvU8lt/FcQFrHqemWtxLavgyujCWVRwEc55A9+lZ2p3Wi6hbh4rG4huWaV3aNwU
BaVmHHoFKjt0rvpPGOg3+lMPEGjW0l6yNvktih55AJYEEZ9ieK4LxLJosPh+wg03zDcMq+exTAZto3EE
qCfm96wavq7fqdEbX0ujk5H3HA6UzHFbuheHLjVB5xUiEdCe9bQ8F5BLnBz0Fc8q0Yux2RoTkro4eiu0
k8JQRL3P1NcvqNn9junjByB0pwrRm7IU6UoK7KdesfCfxORIdDuGLBstCfT1FeT1paBqMul61a3UTlWS
Qcj0zzXZh6nJPyehyV6fPB9z6qjtjtBwKf5B9KmUkwow6FQaPmrq52efY+Z/7T07WtJsbKewFrcQp5Ul
98zKQBhTtVck4x3qaHT/AA1FYvBPFqEl0AQl1CylHPqFYqQPb9axLC4ZrE24kiCqdwB4Yk1eR0gQNK2Y
n4YcYVs9uo//AFV5l7dD1OV20Ll54ZvLO1tbqx1KzvVuCAsFvNvlU9soOc89B071mxJdWztaXFpJFK5Y
IkkTKzHoQMjOa0LjU7GyiMcMk7XGflfI2Mv0POfxqnN4nvmljaK6lxDjy/3hwPp6D6VLimGp1fhv4gS2
F5YTarqdxLBaRmH7L5e5nUg4JbIBIO3r7c1JL4et/EVre6j4V1a+luly8lnIuzgkcBgcD6E87favP7u7
guowFs4orjzCzSRsw3AgcbSSOCCePWup8JeJNf8AD8Z/s+1iltZWDPEwHzkd/Ucf0rXm6MnkW5i3+gTQ
aeLoQ3SMoAn8yCRVyc9CVA/X6egqavey6pLbvJHIkrDHzO7Bie43En0716VN8QNYvnht7zQ1Nob6B1WN
x5rBJBIEIzg5CHnArjfGmsahqXiES3sahbU/uo0Pyqmc4FK1luWtXqd9YW0VlYxW8ajbGgUY9qllZSny
9fSoYJPMhDKcqwyD7Vn6lrEGlxHETzTHooNeWrt2PfajGNxblcKSa4zX9Pe4k82IZPcVpPqutX26SO2C
RemM4/GpbZnmTbMi7u+BWsU4O6ZyTtU0aOBkieJtrqQauabp8l3KhQ4O8BcjgnNdFrelJPGWQYYc5pfD
dpKt/aQuwMLOnAHOS3HNddKrzW9TinS5W0z6SEgVFycYAH0pPtEf99fzqGRA+5T905GKr/YIP+ef613O
T6HkqC6nha6LbfZ41bSZFbaAWUMCalj8LafLH81hcDJ5wcf1rUN21rbGVYFwNowDwckKP51YF4+PuYPp
j/CuKMWt2dt2YR8CWeTskuVDHhXQkL+lDfDtsHyboAHsUI/rXQJfbnCZG/Gdp649alF86nk/TrV2HdnH
z/DvUEK+VLBJ65LLn9DT5PCWr27CS2s3VgDnyrhSD+DEE12K6hIcY3f41Zjv5cZbj/eFDimhpnlt3ba1
YGKa881NwaRVdWUjAC5zj/bHQ96rJZNeaY87o8l0z7kfzBkoAcgrjkk45rovGs02qa/Y2sDLlofJ3BsA
MzEnPsBg13kTWVpYwWrrCIIY1jTzMdAMDrUPtcaPO7W+1Gxto5Lq5RIUQIsbjBwOPr6VeEM+rWouo8EZ
xXR6pYaXcW4ltFt0mDbSYiM4PbH5UWFuLexlhHJBBJ6+tcNVWlY9jCe/A5A6VNM4W5E29WOMSFUx24/w
rags47aFUBye55NW5C1tMskqfI54BPP5Ut1KkifIAAR2FZ8zejNXTitUYt+3VR3HWneHpY7DVLF5VaT9
+nAGf4h/jUd0uDnPSqyTMkyuhIKEEH0NddCVmmzz8Qm72Pf7ib7NC0nlSy7eqxLuY/Qd6o/22n/PhqX/
AICPXld14l1uWzkiuZ5/IkxgHP1Azisj+0bn+9N/303+FbvEpOyPL9kwa4maLy3BxlTkHI4YH29KsXV5
xCIVZ8Rbn4AySTjqfSsSe+8m+kgYqseRjk+lMvNUi+07ot5ARVyOeg9/euZ+1UrHQkuW5uR3MrzvIIQy
FFVcYbnJ/wDrflTJ7q5EEziYxoP3ZjVfm3EZ3ZHoP5isGHUkIYjCNn+7XUaToWraxDC1vG0MRYyPOzbe
DgDr9PpUfvebUqEUxbLUrmRfLiguZVY/e8s8fU4q3G17dIs0iIsBXcrM6j5TyDjr0PpWrfaPa6XpMsn2
uaaZF+8CSM56en6VgPNMmmQukqgTJhou4UfKo46cAcGm6UmveLjBLRmfp2myX2qXE83mfuItxKDnLk8Z
z6A812NjpU01rcx29xkW1u8zfaJSqgKO5APU4HTvXPaddG2kvwjqsRh3555IQAYP+8atxa8ZopEmSKSJ
lwwBycfpU80XujVRSZQ8W3S6PZwwRx+VdSFZhlCCEByD64JH6Grr3F9BCheI28s0SSeW5HAYZHP0IrEv
bK78SeII/OSSSa4Jy0WOFVThQDwAAMelegTaFJqmku97Z2ker3GyRng3BQqoFCnJ24wBzj8xVzUZRVjT
D1HBvszhl/0aTztS1BXmySqGQkD6AcVYguzNubYyoehZdoP0zSfYDA5WGK3jIOGJXnrViZkii2M24gZJ
rF6ndJpK6ZnXb8ECs+033ExSJWdmOAqjJNaMOk3urk+WwtrTP7y5fp9FH8R/QetdZpenWmkWgS0hbc4w
pPMsvuT2HsOK3hGyuzzqlTXQoafo0kQ3X0gYYAELHcq/Xt+Aq/8AYLH/AJ9rT/vwK1YrORE8yUgzH7qj
on09T707ybr+89dKSaON6nlj6dqE0s32eSRYpGyVBwDj+dNj0PUfOJCwOgG398BV6I6jbTiSKGaL/a8n
J/Ktawv7e+uQl9KqJyCSCPw64H1xUtblR7FTQNCiW8kn1SxFy0bqYLe3AKyY5OemB27V3z3106ZltpYY
wMgAqQPwXj8qr250yMeT5pW3VQ+1FYjGeCWPD/nTZpT5jQorPHnAYAgEeoJ/zn9BJG8VbRHKeKdaa2jN
puAkdiV7jGa5S1N9NC8iHCjIBOSCaveJNLmg1+WOSQz+ed1sT1Kk9PzrTg0PULGxEAs3Y4yTu28988dK
zqVFDQ1pUpVHczLL7ZNBKkLxBZVCuOARyD/QVqaN4b1rWL8WkSoFJAeZlJEak9c4wT7f/rqPS9Kkhn3z
QtE45+vtXf6RrLWMkaxgJGh5jHQ1kuV3sEqLg1fY6q08K6doemra2caquM3E7Ab5QOoJ9D+WM9KSS0LK
wPWTv0z/APWq5cXg1BdOgh+ZbpxJIV/55qNx/PAH41cu1WNHlkYAY5YnoKwjNt2ZvKCS0PJdc0iT+0Ss
HyxqxM0pBYgdsAY5rOtrGCK6eS6gklgCZVZG5LZGOB7Z4NdhfXFxfXUi6dDkk7d5GFX6n19qmsNASGHE
4Ms7PveRjx0xjH5VrHe5jKTSszn7aO4v5Q5iAReEToi/41v2unmMl2JaRurkfoB6VqR2kcQwqCnlQDgV
qjmkyn9nCnI79SaPL9x+dXNgwc80eUn90VqtjE4eC8iYbWKq3dDj/Jqr/wAI/p+qagHjcx7XDybehHp7
UeRCRgIpU9h1H0rQ01dlrcL8jxnAZsAY9Aam3K9C46s1ZYkFswREOVIVQR6cde1Ymi+JYL62k0ueMfbY
i2I8YD7e6H168H9e0MlxDawol7f29mzfw8bn/DtTV0u2vlvHsIngkkjCpdFiGduvA6YHGcDuKFdHVZGF
fG5e/h1IK7y2komXA/hB+b8MV6jFd2l9YpPbqrRsvBH8jXLWF2/9hSLkLdx28kU4b72Qp3Z9cjJz71xu
k6/CMRW9y8UnoxK1z4mm6tmuh1YSsqV4y6ndamU80DAHNYE13tmucOAFQ8579KestxO3mTYO3kvuyTWD
4vuI4zp5t2ZS7tvX1HH+NZ0YtSsb4qSlTcj2T4dRm50UXsgJO544yT/DkZ/UY/Ct/Vbc3ZWEk+WPmYA4
zVDwAyDwTpmwHHkjOf72SW/8eJrVvJCFIXqx7is7++znWxkfZo1lLooVRwqgYA9f8+1O24qZxxjsKY3T
HeuuOxyyKzZ+6vX19KRUAGP1qYqAKbtrRHPIiK+go2mmyzYkEMeDI3Pso9TTcXP/AD0j/wC+apTRnY81
juA9jJco22KPAY45DHoOe5/oaZZaqgk2ysdxPHPB/Dpms22ku9V8mw8w+UhLqiLgKOpbA64HUn866LTf
C9mY4rm4uV8jIO5ztU/5/L3q9EtSo3voW7a0R5fNMKSA8o7KASSPQDgD1q1IokmhX7QF+bEaImfr3qzP
eabDEXecQ2qLkndlpBjgKAOSWwKpeFLiDU4n+2hldJN4lVDmM9MdOP5fjWbcbXbN4SfRFfWNNlnWSeyc
RzkeXOwUbmUc4/8A1cnpXn3iK0t44ku+PtHmeUxj6Hg/e9CMV7BqdkVv457SQTK2PNUcHA9q4p7C1u/E
+qW80ayWtxG4k3EgKcBg3A6qRx78U1HqKVpaHI6brUlpGUilLqB0k6D6Vmancvf3QuZpgSMKEH1q34j0
M+H9bfT2uBMoRZEYDGQc9vwqsPMu2WBnBDkAEr90+oxWnLFPmsR7Wo4+zbPov4ezCXwTYMvTDrz7Ow/p
W7ITK5bHGcAVw/wrkuF0O6sZORb3BCHHTcATXesqomeigfpXlS0m2d6fupFGRcZqA8VNBOLy1S4C7Uk+
ZOeq54P4jmopTgmt4PQ56is7MjOOp6VXurpLa2edgSFHAHUnsBTmbe+M8DrVKX/S7xV6xQncR/ebsPw6
1d7mDJNPhaOMy3BzPKdz+g9B9BV75f7q/lVYyJErOx6cVH/aMfqKpSSRk9TpbfSNI0yxYWFnbQZG2Vo4
wC4HXc3U/jXHRiLV5Z7tkBtLYmGxhxhUC/KWA9TyPYD3NVrHx/Z6xoshM621yE/eRyHn6L65/SpdF2xa
FbomMbN3ByOeTz9TXDU5orXc7MKlzNnJ2Ni1t4mEUwxbOrPE+37sw6YPupb8QO4FTajPcaJqMd/bszPE
TkfwyL3GPwH5CtXVMrH50SgmBhJjrkA5pbu3gvtMDZQKyjBx97JGO56/0HrXXQlGpGzQVk6U1JGnNFZ6
7pceo2Z2+Ymfl6c9QRXGX+qroMcol08v5koMkqgnKjt7Dj1707w1rDeHNV+wXORYyngHov0+ld9dabb3
kPmRbHRhkEcg1gqk6EuWWqO32dOvDnjueHalrljrGrS3s1kzGRVQMzkYAGOn6/jWOXkhvIjbtjByG7fQ
16hr3gS2uS0sSeTN13IOD9R3rzzUNB1PSZHNzCzR7t3moMr14+ld9KrCorI82rSnTdz3P4b2oXQEuBKr
PdMXdVH+rI4I/ID867eSMONuMg9j6V498MPEcdijW9y4EUhA3H+DHQ/SvYVlUx+Zng9K8/ERcJnRCpzK
5SuNsY2gAADAA7CsuTJz71pSK0zHHSqk0ezOe3SnT1M5uxl3cv2W2dgNzY4A6k9hVC3aWCAQ7185humc
dFJ64pNQut2oR26fMyjeR79v6/lVaVjtMKHg/fbuxrZHO2PeY3UohjP7pe/rT/sQ96fZW+zoKvbD6irV
1sTc/9k=
Comment 1 Stephan Kulow 2003-09-23 21:20:43 UTC 
it's no attachment, it's a image/jpeg mail. I'm not kmail supports that. possible wishlist 
duplicate.
Comment 2 Stephan Kulow 2003-09-23 21:35:20 UTC 
quite special case
Comment 3 Thomas Bevan 2003-09-29 01:17:38 UTC 
I just attached the file in the normal way. I don't see that it is really a 
special case. It must be quite common to attach binaries without any sort of a 
message.
Comment 4 Marc Mutz 2003-09-30 11:24:29 UTC 
Subject: Re:  Attachment is dropped when forwarding empty emails

On Monday 29 September 2003 01:17, Thomas Bevan wrote:
<snip>
> I just attached the file in the normal way. I don't see that it is
> really a special case. It must be quite common to attach binaries
> without any sort of a message.
<snip>

You try "forward inline", right? Of couse that does not include 
attachments. It includes text only - hence "inline". Use the non-
obsolete and more robust "forward as attachment" to forward the 
attachments, too.

Marc
Comment 5 Ingo Klöcker 2004-01-28 10:19:39 UTC 
*** Bug 73656 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***
Comment 6 Rudolf Kollien 2004-01-28 14:33:10 UTC 
As of KDE 3.1.4 KMail honors attachments when forwarding a message inline. But not when the message contains _only_ an attachment and _no_ text. 

It is very, very difficult to instruct a novice user when he/she has to forward a mail as inline an when he/she can "normal" forward. Especially for migrating users two different forward options are very confusing. 

Previous to KDE 3.1.4 we used redirect to forward messages as with this feature all attachments where honored. But redirecting has disadvantages. Mostly on answering to the mail.

Forwarding a message inline also has some disadvatages. For example you are not able to print the forwarded (attached) message. But there is already a rfe for such a feature on the wishlist in this bugzilla.
Comment 7 Ingo Klöcker 2004-02-02 16:40:51 UTC 
*** Bug 74015 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***
Comment 8 Ferdinand Gassauer 2004-10-05 16:14:16 UTC 
choosing the default forwad action in KMail 1.7.1 attachments are not forwarded at all
cu
ferdinand
Comment 9 Sergey Y. Afonin 2004-10-13 22:44:37 UTC 
Ferdinand, please compare #60960 with #91132 and give your opinion.
Comment 10 Ingo Klöcker 2004-10-16 01:43:18 UTC 
The problem mentioned in comment #8 has been resolved for KDE 3.3.2 (it's only broken in KDE 3.3.1).
Comment 11 Jeffrey Froman 2004-10-22 17:03:50 UTC 
Even if forwarding "inline" does not include attachments, surely "redirect" should? Using KMail 1.7.1 and KDE 3.3.1, attachments are not included when redirecting.
Comment 12 Till Adam 2004-10-24 13:11:27 UTC 
This was recently fixed for KDE 3.3.2 as well.
Comment 13 Andres Kärner 2004-12-23 14:58:49 UTC 
How recently? I have 3.3.2 and this bug still exists.