Bug 145708 - Relative paths are not correctly managed in the configuration dialog
Summary: Relative paths are not correctly managed in the configuration dialog
Status: RESOLVED FIXED
Alias: None
Product: kdevelop
Classification: Applications
Component: Build tools: QMake (show other bugs)
Version: 3.4.1
Platform: unspecified Linux
: NOR normal
Target Milestone: ---
Assignee: Andreas Pakulat
URL:
Keywords:
Depends on:
Blocks:
 
Reported: 2007-05-20 14:48 UTC by Alessandro Garberi
Modified: 2007-05-25 03:15 UTC (History)
0 users

See Also:
Latest Commit:
Version Fixed In:
Sentry Crash Report:


Attachments

Note You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.
Description Alessandro Garberi 2007-05-20 14:48:28 UTC
Version:           3.4.1 (using KDE 3.5.5, Debian Package 4:3.5.5a.dfsg.1-8 (4.0))
Compiler:          Target: i486-linux-gnu
OS:                Linux (i686) release 2.6.18-4-k7

Hi,
relative paths in "QMake Subproject Configuration" are not always correctly managed.
Here some examples:
- in "Basics" TAB, "Target Path" in my .pro file is relative (something like '../../bin'), but it is shown in the dialog as an absolute path as '/path/to/project/../../bin' (anyway it is correctly saved as a relative path in the .pro file)
- in "Includes" TAB, "Directories outside project" I have a relative dir (something like '../xml' and it is shown correctly, but if I select it and click "Edit" button, an error message is shown ("The specified folder does not exist or was not readable.") and then the proposed dir is '/path/to/project../xml' with a missing '/' before '..';
morevoer if I accept the proposed dir (after correcting it) it is saved as an absolute dir ('/path/to/project/../xml') but this may be a wanted feature because of the field name ("Directories outside project").

Little suggestion:
to concatenate a base dir and a relative path, you may use "QFileInfo::QFileInfo(const QDir &d, const QString &fileName)"; example: "QFileInfo(baseDir, relativePath).absFilePath()".
Comment 1 Andreas Pakulat 2007-05-20 16:59:36 UTC
As for the first point: Thats by purpose so people can easily look for a target and as you can see a relative path is stored, so I don't see a bug there.

The second point is a bug indeed, I'll put it onto my todo list, but I can't do much at the moment as KDE 3.5 is in freeze. Also I doubt that there will be another release of KDevelop (except maybe our own binaries) because development on KDE3 is supposed to fade out.
Comment 2 Andreas Pakulat 2007-05-25 03:15:45 UTC
SVN commit 668071 by apaku:

Fix several issues with the url requesters, they should now behave as expected.
Also includes fixes from Bernd Buschinski
BUG:145708
CCMAIL:b.buschinski@web.de

 M  +116 -26   projectconfigurationdlg.cpp  


--- branches/KDE/3.5/kdevelop/buildtools/qmake/projectconfigurationdlg.cpp #668070:668071
@@ -395,8 +395,8 @@
     }
 
     QString targetpath = m_targetPath->url();
-    if( !QFileInfo( targetpath ).isRelative() )
-        targetpath = URLUtil::getRelativePath( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir(), targetpath );
+//     if( !QFileInfo( targetpath ).isRelative() )
+//         targetpath = URLUtil::getRelativePath( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir(), targetpath );
     if( myProjectItem->scope->scopeType() == Scope::FunctionScope || myProjectItem->scope->scopeType() == Scope::SimpleScope )
     {
         if( myProjectItem->scope->variableValues("TARGET").findIndex( m_targetOutputFile->text() ) == -1 )
@@ -572,6 +572,7 @@
     myProjectItem->scope->setEqualOp( "OBJECTS_DIR", QStringList( objdir_url->url() ) );
     myProjectItem->scope->setEqualOp( "UI_DIR", QStringList( uidir_url->url() ) );
     myProjectItem->scope->setEqualOp( "MOC_DIR", QStringList( mocdir_url->url() ) );
+    myProjectItem->scope->setEqualOp( "RCC_DIR", QStringList( rccdir_url->url() ) );
 
     //CORBA
     myProjectItem->scope->setEqualOp( "IDL_COMPILER", QStringList( idlCmdEdit->url() ) );
@@ -679,8 +680,20 @@
         if( targetname.findRev("/") != -1 )
             targetname = targetname.right( targetname.length() - targetname.findRev("/") - 1 );
         m_editRunArguments->setText( DomUtil::readEntry( *prjWidget->m_part->projectDom(), "/kdevtrollproject/run/runarguments/"+targetname, "" ) );
-        m_CWDEdit->setURL( DomUtil::readEntry( *prjWidget->m_part->projectDom(), "/kdevtrollproject/run/cwd/"+targetname, "" ) );
-        m_CWDEdit->fileDialog()->setURL( KURL::fromPathOrURL( DomUtil::readEntry( *prjWidget->m_part->projectDom(), "/kdevtrollproject/run/cwd/"+targetname, "" ) ) );
+
+        QString dir = DomUtil::readEntry( *prjWidget->m_part->projectDom(), "/kdevtrollproject/run/cwd/"+targetname, "" );
+        if( QFileInfo(dir).isRelative() )
+        {
+            m_CWDEdit->completionObject()->setDir( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir() );
+            m_CWDEdit->fileDialog()->setURL( KURL( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir()+"/"+dir ) );
+        }else
+        {
+
+            m_CWDEdit->completionObject()->setDir( dir);
+            m_CWDEdit->fileDialog()->setURL( KURL( dir ) );
+        }
+        m_CWDEdit->setURL( dir );
+
         if( m_CWDEdit->url().isEmpty() )
         {
             QString destdir = myProjectItem->m_widget->getCurrentDestDir();
@@ -835,8 +848,17 @@
     }
     editConfigExtra->setText( extraValues.join( " " ) );
 
-    //makefile
-    makefile_url->setURL( myProjectItem->scope->variableValues( "MAKEFILE" ).front() );
+    QString dir = myProjectItem->scope->variableValues( "MAKEFILE" ).front();
+    if( QFileInfo(dir).isRelative() )
+    {
+        makefile_url->completionObject()->setDir( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir() );
+        makefile_url->fileDialog()->setURL( KURL( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir()+"/"+dir ) );
+    }else
+    {
+        makefile_url->completionObject()->setDir( dir );
+        makefile_url->fileDialog()->setURL( KURL( dir ) );
+    }
+    makefile_url->setURL( dir );
 
     if ( myProjectItem->scope->variableValues( "INSTALLS" ).findIndex( "target" ) != -1 )
     {
@@ -851,8 +873,19 @@
     m_InstallTargetPath->setText( myProjectItem->scope->variableValues( "target.path" ).front() );
 
     m_targetOutputFile->setText( myProjectItem->scope->variableValues( "TARGET" ).front() );
-    m_targetPath->setURL( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir()+"/"+myProjectItem->scope->variableValues( "DESTDIR" ).front() );
 
+    dir = myProjectItem->scope->variableValues( "DESTDIR" ).front();
+    if( QFileInfo(dir).isRelative() )
+    {
+        m_targetPath->completionObject()->setDir( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir() );
+        m_targetPath->fileDialog()->setURL( KURL( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir()+"/"+dir ) );
+    }else
+    {
+        m_targetPath->completionObject()->setDir( dir );
+        m_targetPath->fileDialog()->setURL( KURL( dir ) );
+    }
+    m_targetPath->setURL( dir );
+
     m_defines->setText( myProjectItem->scope->variableValues( "DEFINES" ).join( " " ) );
     m_debugFlags->setText( myProjectItem->scope->variableValues( "QMAKE_CXXFLAGS_DEBUG" ).join( " " ) );
     m_releaseFlags->setText( myProjectItem->scope->variableValues( "QMAKE_CXXFLAGS_RELEASE" ).join( " " ) );
@@ -862,11 +895,63 @@
     updateBuildOrderControl();
     updateDependenciesControl();
 
-    objdir_url->setURL( myProjectItem->scope->variableValues( "OBJECTS_DIR" ).front() );
-    uidir_url->setURL( myProjectItem->scope->variableValues( "UI_DIR" ).front() );
-    mocdir_url->setURL( myProjectItem->scope->variableValues( "MOC_DIR" ).front() );
+    dir = myProjectItem->scope->variableValues( "OBJECTS_DIR" ).front();
+    if( QFileInfo(dir).isRelative() )
+    {
+        objdir_url->completionObject()->setDir( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir() );
+        objdir_url->fileDialog()->setURL( KURL( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir()+"/"+dir ) );
+    }else
+    {
+        objdir_url->completionObject()->setDir( dir );
+        objdir_url->fileDialog()->setURL( KURL( dir ) );
+    }
+    objdir_url->setURL( dir );
+    dir = myProjectItem->scope->variableValues( "UI_DIR" ).front();
+    if( QFileInfo(dir).isRelative() )
+    {
+        uidir_url->completionObject()->setDir( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir() );
+        uidir_url->fileDialog()->setURL( KURL( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir()+"/"+dir ) );
+    }else
+    {
+        uidir_url->completionObject()->setDir( dir );
+        uidir_url->fileDialog()->setURL( KURL( dir ) );
+    }
+    uidir_url->setURL( dir );
+    dir = myProjectItem->scope->variableValues( "MOC_DIR" ).front();
+    if( QFileInfo(dir).isRelative() )
+    {
+        mocdir_url->completionObject()->setDir( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir() );
+        mocdir_url->fileDialog()->setURL( KURL( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir()+"/"+dir ) );
+    }else
+    {
+        mocdir_url->completionObject()->setDir( dir );
+        mocdir_url->fileDialog()->setURL( KURL( dir ) );
+    }
+    mocdir_url->setURL( dir );
+    dir = myProjectItem->scope->variableValues( "RC_DIR" ).front();
+    if( QFileInfo(dir).isRelative() )
+    {
+        rccdir_url->completionObject()->setDir( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir() );
+        rccdir_url->fileDialog()->setURL( KURL( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir()+"/"+dir ) );
+    }else
+    {
+        rccdir_url->completionObject()->setDir( dir );
+        rccdir_url->fileDialog()->setURL( KURL( dir ) );
+    }
+    rccdir_url->setURL( dir );
 
-    idlCmdEdit->setURL( myProjectItem->scope->variableValues( "IDL_COMPILER" ).front() );
+
+    dir = myProjectItem->scope->variableValues( "IDL_COMPILER" ).front();
+    if( QFileInfo(dir).isRelative() )
+    {
+        idlCmdEdit->completionObject()->setDir( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir() );
+        idlCmdEdit->fileDialog()->setURL( KURL( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir()+"/"+dir ) );
+    }else
+    {
+        idlCmdEdit->completionObject()->setDir( dir );
+        idlCmdEdit->fileDialog()->setURL( KURL( dir ) );
+    }
+    idlCmdEdit->setURL( dir );
     idlCmdOptionsEdit->setText( myProjectItem->scope->variableValues( "IDL_OPTIONS" ).join( " " ) );
 
     customVariables->clear();
@@ -1388,18 +1473,17 @@
 
     KURLRequesterDlg dialog( text, i18n( "Change include directory:" ), 0, 0 );
     dialog.urlRequester() ->setMode( KFile::Directory | KFile::LocalOnly );
-    if( !text.startsWith( "/" ) )
+    if( QFileInfo(text).isRelative() )
     {
-        dialog.urlRequester() ->completionObject() ->setDir( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir()+text );
-        dialog.urlRequester() ->fileDialog() ->setURL( KURL( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir()+text ) );
-        dialog.urlRequester() ->setURL( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir()+text );
+        dialog.urlRequester() ->completionObject() ->setDir( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir() );
+        dialog.urlRequester() ->fileDialog() ->setURL( KURL( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir()+"/"+text ) );
     }
     else
     {
         dialog.urlRequester() ->completionObject() ->setDir( text );
         dialog.urlRequester() ->fileDialog() ->setURL( KURL( text ) );
-        dialog.urlRequester() ->setURL( text );
     }
+    dialog.urlRequester() ->setURL( text );
     if ( dialog.exec() != QDialog::Accepted )
         return ;
     QString dir = dialog.urlRequester() ->url();
@@ -1418,9 +1502,16 @@
 
     KURLRequesterDlg dialog( text, i18n( "Change Library:" ), 0, 0 );
     dialog.urlRequester() ->setMode( KFile::File | KFile::ExistingOnly | KFile::LocalOnly );
+    if( QFileInfo(text).isRelative() )
+    {
+        dialog.urlRequester() ->completionObject() ->setDir( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir() );
+        dialog.urlRequester() ->fileDialog() ->setURL( KURL( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir()+"/"+text ) );
+    }else
+    {
         dialog.urlRequester() ->completionObject() ->setDir( text );
         dialog.urlRequester() ->fileDialog() ->setURL( KURL( text ) );
-        dialog.urlRequester() ->setURL( text );
+    }
+    dialog.urlRequester() ->setURL( text );
     if ( dialog.exec() != QDialog::Accepted )
         return ;
     QString file = dialog.urlRequester() ->url();
@@ -1468,18 +1559,17 @@
     KURLRequesterDlg dialog( text, i18n( "Change library directory:" ), 0, 0 );
     dialog.urlRequester() ->setMode( KFile::Directory | KFile::LocalOnly );
 
-    if( !text.startsWith( "/" ) )
+    if( QFileInfo(text).isRelative() )
     {
-        dialog.urlRequester() ->completionObject() ->setDir( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir()+text );
-        dialog.urlRequester() ->fileDialog() ->setURL( KURL( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir()+text ) );
-        dialog.urlRequester() ->setURL( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir()+text );
+        dialog.urlRequester() ->completionObject() ->setDir( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir() );
+        dialog.urlRequester() ->fileDialog() ->setURL( KURL( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir()+"/"+text ) );
     }
     else
     {
         dialog.urlRequester() ->completionObject() ->setDir( text );
         dialog.urlRequester() ->fileDialog() ->setURL( KURL( text ) );
-        dialog.urlRequester() ->setURL( text );
     }
+    dialog.urlRequester() ->setURL( text );
     if ( dialog.exec() != QDialog::Accepted )
         return ;
     QString dir = dialog.urlRequester() ->url();
@@ -1516,17 +1606,17 @@
 
     KURLRequesterDlg dialog( text, i18n( "Change target:" ), 0, 0 );
     dialog.urlRequester() ->setMode( KFile::File | KFile::LocalOnly );
-    dialog.urlRequester() ->setURL( QString::null );
-    if( !text.startsWith( "/" ) )
+    if( QFileInfo(text).isRelative() )
     {
-        dialog.urlRequester() ->completionObject() ->setDir( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir()+text );
-        dialog.urlRequester() ->fileDialog() ->setURL( KURL( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir()+text ) );
+        dialog.urlRequester() ->completionObject() ->setDir( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir() );
+        dialog.urlRequester() ->fileDialog() ->setURL( KURL( myProjectItem->scope->projectDir()+"/"+text ) );
     }
     else
     {
         dialog.urlRequester() ->completionObject() ->setDir( text );
         dialog.urlRequester() ->fileDialog() ->setURL( KURL( text ) );
     }
+    dialog.urlRequester() ->setURL( text );
     if ( dialog.exec() != QDialog::Accepted )
         return ;
     QString path = dialog.urlRequester() ->url();