Version: 0.5.82 (using KDE Devel) Installed from: Compiled sources OS: I Don't Know okular's configuration dialog in KDE alpha 1 violates one of KDE's configuration dialog HIGs[1]; in the left pane, the label "Accessibility" has a page titled "Reading Aids". [1]: http://wiki.kde.org/tiki-index.php?page=Checklist+1%3A+Configuration+Dialogs
On Sun, May 13, 2007 at 12:33:55AM -0000, Samat Jain wrote: Hi, > okular's configuration dialog in KDE alpha 1 violates one of KDE's configuration dialog HIGs[1]; > in the left pane, the label "Accessibility" has a page titled "Reading Aids". I don't see why it shouldn't match. 'Reading Aids' sounds like a valid subtitle for Accessibility. What title do you suggest? Ciao, Tobias
I followed the links, and http://wiki.openusability.org/guidelines/index.php/Checklist_Configuration_Dialogs says: CL1/3.3 The overall size of the dialog shouldn't be bigger than 800x600. Is that what you are concerned about?
As Brad already said, 3.3 is about the size of the dialog. Here it opens with an initial size smaller than 600 x 600, including KDE3 Plastik windows decoration and dialog buttons, so no problem on that side. For the page title, if the Accessibility one violates something (which I don't really believe), then all the other pages do that as well.
He think he means CL1/4.1 BUT i'm really against blind changes like that, so before the change i would like someone from the Usability Team explaining the reasoning behind 4.1
Reassigning to the mailing list
SVN commit 689887 by pino: Give a "better" subtitle for the Accessibility configuration page so it's more "compliant" (but it was also before, IMHO) to the new HIG. BUG: 145368 M +1 -1 preferencesdialog.cpp --- trunk/KDE/kdegraphics/okular/conf/preferencesdialog.cpp #689886:689887 @@ -31,7 +31,7 @@ m_debug = new DlgDebug(0); addPage( m_general, i18n("General"), "okular", i18n("General Options") ); - addPage( m_accessibility, i18n("Accessibility"), "access", i18n("Reading Aids") ); + addPage( m_accessibility, i18n("Accessibility"), "access", i18n("Accessibility Reading Aids") ); addPage( m_performance, i18n("Performance"), "launch", i18n("Performance Tuning") ); addPage( m_presentation, i18n("Presentation"), "kpresenter_kpr", i18n("Options for Presentation Mode") );