Bug 68818

Summary:	Accidentally cross linked libraries cause endless looping and eventually crash.
Product:	[Applications] kdevelop	Reporter:	nick smethurst <nick.smethurst>
Component:	Build tools: Automake	Assignee:	KDevelop Developers <kdevelop-devel>
Status:	RESOLVED FIXED
Severity:	crash
Priority:	NOR
Version:	unspecified
Target Milestone:	---
Platform:	Compiled Sources
OS:	Linux
Latest Commit:		Version Fixed In:
Sentry Crash Report:

Description nick smethurst 2003-11-23 01:34:17 UTC

Version:            (using KDE Devel)
Installed from:    Compiled sources
Compiler:          gcc 3.3.1 
OS:          Linux

In auto project, if a project contains two libtool libraries and they are mistakenly crosslinked, KDevelop enters into an endless loop when the user types F7 to compile, and eventually crashes:

A bit of the resulting kdebug output (full directory paths not shown):

kdevelop (auto project):

Scheduling : < .. /src/libkvvtk/>  target <libkvvtk.la>
Looking for path src/libkvvtk
 ... checking -/ .. -
 ... (tailored: -- against -src/libkvvtk- )
 ... checking -/ .. /doc-
 ... (tailored: -doc- against -src/libkvvtk- )
 ... checking -/ .. /doc/en-
 ... (tailored: -doc/en- against -src/libkvvtk- )
 ... checking -/ .. /po-
 ... (tailored: -po- against -src/libkvvtk- )
 ... checking -/ .. /src-
 ... (tailored: -src- against -src/libkvvtk- )
 ... checking -/ .. /src/libkvisualiser-
 ... (tailored: -src/libkvisualiser- against -src/libkvvtk- )
 ... checking -/ .. /src/libkvvtk-
 ... (tailored: -src/libkvvtk- against -src/libkvvtk- )
Found it!
Found config optimized
Found config debug
Scheduling : < .. /src/libkvisualiser/>  target <libkvisualiser.la>
Looking for path src/libkvisualiser
 ... checking -/ .. -
 ... (tailored: -- against -src/libkvisualiser- )
 ... checking -/ .. /doc-
 ... (tailored: -doc- against -src/libkvisualiser- )
 ... checking -/ .. /doc/en-
 ... (tailored: -doc/en- against -src/libkvisualiser- )
 ... checking -/ .. /po-
 ... (tailored: -po- against -src/libkvisualiser- )
 ... checking -/ .. /src-
 ... (tailored: -src- against -src/libkvisualiser- )
 ... checking -/ .. /src/libkvisualiser-
 ... (tailored: -src/libkvisualiser- against -src/libkvisualiser- )
Found it!
Found config optimized
Found config debug
Scheduling : < .. /src/libkvvtk/>  target <libkvvtk.la>
Looking for path src/libkvvtk
 ... checking -/ .. -
 ... (tailored: -- against -src/libkvvtk- )
 ... checking -/ .. /doc-
 ... (tailored: -doc- against -src/libkvvtk- )
 ... checking -/ .. /doc/en-
 ... (tailored: -doc/en- against -src/libkvvtk- )
 ... checking -/ .. /po-
 ... (tailored: -po- against -src/libkvvtk- )
 ... checking -/ .. /src-
 ... (tailored: -src- against -src/libkvvtk- )
 ... checking -/ .. /src/libkvisualiser-
 ... (tailored: -src/libkvisualiser- against -src/libkvvtk- )
 ... checking -/ .. /src/libkvvtk-
 ... (tailored: -src/libkvvtk- against -src/libkvvtk- )
Found it!
Found config optimized

and so on ..

Maybe there should be some kind of check for this user error which prevents the crash?

Comment 1 Amilcar do Carmo Lucas 2003-11-23 14:08:38 UTC

OK, I'll take a look at it

Comment 2 Amilcar do Carmo Lucas 2003-11-23 14:27:12 UTC

The problem is in the recursive function:
void AutoProjectPart::queueInternalLibDependenciesBuild(TargetItem* titem)
that starts around line buildtools/autotools/autoprojectpart.cpp:665 

The fix seams to be non trivial due to the async nature of the function.
Besides that we need to issue an error to the user, and we are currently in a string freeze, so I'll postpone this one for after the release.

Thanks for reporting.

Comment 3 Amilcar do Carmo Lucas 2004-01-21 15:10:37 UTC

Reopen, because the REMIND state "hides" the bug

Comment 4 Andreas Pakulat 2007-11-30 17:40:46 UTC

SVN commit 743327 by apaku:

Check for circular dependecies and tell the user if one is found.
BUG:68818

 M  +62 -37    autoprojectpart.cpp  
 M  +1 -1      autoprojectpart.h  


WebSVN link: http://websvn.kde.org/?view=rev&revision=743327