| Summary: | Set contact information for contacts not on your visable Contact List | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Product: | [Unmaintained] kopete | Reporter: | Casey Allen Shobe <cshobe> |
| Component: | libkopete | Assignee: | Kopete Developers <kopete-bugs-null> |
| Status: | RESOLVED INTENTIONAL | ||
| Severity: | wishlist | ||
| Priority: | NOR | ||
| Version: | unspecified | ||
| Target Milestone: | --- | ||
| Platform: | Compiled Sources | ||
| OS: | Linux | ||
| Latest Commit: | Version Fixed In: | ||
| Sentry Crash Report: | |||
|
Description
Casey Allen Shobe
2003-10-25 16:46:51 UTC
If you want to store information add the contact. and when you remove the contact, we assume we don't want to keep informations. I would like to close this bug as WONTFIX I agree with Oliver, We aren't running a persistant userinfo SQL database here, it is a contact list. If you want the information persistant for someone then he should be on the list, or store it in KAB. Having every person in the world who ever messages you on your list is pure rediculousness. There is however a need to see something beyond the contact ID when a contact messages you. It would also be nice to use the notes plugin and add a note saying "deleted because <blah>" on the account, and then be able to pull that up when he messages you out of the blue one day. Subject: Re: [Kopete-devel] Set contact information for contacts not on your visable Contact List On October 28, 2003 3:11 pm, Casey Allen Shobe wrote: > ------- Having every person in the world who ever messages you on your list > is pure rediculousness. It's also pure rediculousness to want to save some kind of contact notes for people who aren't even important enough to have on your list. What do you want to even put there? > There is however a need to see something beyond > the contact ID when a contact messages you. Like what? > It would also be nice to use the notes plugin and add a note saying > "deleted because <blah>" on the account, and then be able to pull that up > when he messages you out of the blue one day. Then make a deleted users plugin that keeps track of this kind of baloney. It isn't up to libkopete to keep track of deleted contacts. > What do you want to even put there? Stop replying without reading. I'll copy/paste: "It would also be nice to use the notes plugin and add a note saying "deleted because <blah>" on the account, and then be able to pull that up when he messages you out of the blue one day." > Like what? Gee, what do you think? Stuff that's only stored for on-list contacts. > Then make a deleted users plugin that keeps track of this kind of baloney. > It isn't up to libkopete to keep track of deleted contacts. Well excuse me for having an idea that you think of as baloney. But most of your ideas are quite a bit worse - the only difference is that you just go ahead with them anyways. As it would happen, having a not-visable list would solve a bunch of problems with interactions with users not on your contact list. That was the original inspiration for this idea. Subject: Re: [Kopete-devel] Set contact information for contacts not on your visable Contact List
> As it would happen, having a not-visable list would solve a bunch of
> problems with interactions with users not on your contact list. That was
> the original inspiration for this idea.
What is one such problem this would help solve?
> What is one such problem this would help solve?
Deleting contacts closes open chatwindow wouldn't happen, because the contact would not be truly deleted.
Inability to chat with people not on your list (as a result, that temp contact muck exists, and you still cannot open chats with people not on your list who don't message you first) would go away.
Accidental deletion wouldn't be so catastrophic.
etc.
Subject: Re: [Kopete-devel] Set contact information for contacts not on your visable Contact List On October 28, 2003 4:19 pm, Casey Allen Shobe wrote: > Inability to chat with people not on your list (as a result, that temp > contact muck exists, All IM clients have a temporary contact list. > Deleting contacts closes open chatwindow wouldn't happen, because the > contact would not be truly deleted. This is a unrelated issue that needs to be resolved anyway by the individual protocols. As I said before IRC doesn't have this problem and as such it isn't a proble with kopete itself, but with a protocol plugin. > and you still cannot open chats with people not on > your list who don't message you first) would go away. This is blatendly false. I can message people on IRC who aren't on my list and I do so frequently. I can also message people who arent on my list with Jabber and SMS and MSN. You are talking about making protocol-specific decisions by adding stuff to kopete core, which is not a good premise. |