Summary: | Allow the user to switch off the drag and drop context menu | ||
---|---|---|---|
Product: | [Applications] dolphin | Reporter: | jimbo <loudsquid> |
Component: | general | Assignee: | Dolphin Bug Assignee <dolphin-bugs-null> |
Status: | RESOLVED DUPLICATE | ||
Severity: | wishlist | CC: | advice2020, kfm-devel, papamarkoua |
Priority: | NOR | ||
Version: | 22.04.1 | ||
Target Milestone: | --- | ||
Platform: | Other | ||
OS: | Linux | ||
Latest Commit: | Version Fixed In: | ||
Sentry Crash Report: |
Description
jimbo
2022-05-24 19:22:46 UTC
I agree with this as well, this one is so important to me. KDE Plasma is amazing, this is literally one of the only things I can find that I do not care for, makes it very difficult to use. I am aware that you can use modifier keys to avoid them but for such a standard action should not really have to use a keyboard modifier to simple drag and drop a file with left mouse button. To me personally this is a pretty big deal, hopefully this could finally be addressed. There was a post requesting this from a long time ago (over 10 years ago) it had over 120 votes for it but unfortunately was never able to be fixed and I think the post was deleted? Nothing wrong with having these context menus be the default for those who like them, but seems odd that KDE, a group known for endless customization / settings, does not have an option to be able to turn these off / allow users to choose how drag & drops perform. I have never seen any other file managers use this approach with LMB D&D so with something that is far away from a standard, again seems odd not to be able to have a setting for something like this. I have however seen in Windows as well as some FM in Linux the use of the RMB D&D for these context menus which I would prefer. RMB makes more sense because a single click brings up context menu so D&D with RMB to bring up these CM would fit in better here. I will also add something not mentioned. This request is under the "Dolphin" category but it is a global issue throughout Plasma and all KDE products. I read in that old request post that apparently these context menus are coming from a file/library that all KDE products use. I have noticed them in Plasma, Dolphin and Krusader, even shows up in the Dolphin Flatpak. I posted a more in depth post about how this could possibly be handled here if anyone is interested https://discuss.kde.org/t/plasma-dolphin-drag-drop-context-menus/1809 Thank You Hopefully this one will be considered *** This bug has been marked as a duplicate of bug 154804 *** This context menu is one of the most frustrating desktop UI features of the past two decades. Some argue it’s about safety to prevent mistakes, but that’s not valid anymore—Dolphin already has an Undo feature for those rare instances. Just how frustrating is it? Imagine a workday where you're tasked with organizing 1,000 PDFs moving them to customers folders. Instead of completing the job in 3 hours with 1,000 clicks, you end up doubling that time to 6 hours with 2,000 clicks—all because you’re forced to react on same menu with the same option 1000 times! Even the most patient person would lose their mind. The mental strain is so intense, you might even consider switching desktop environment. Is there already a solution? Not really. Some suggest using a modifier key like Shift, Alt, or Control to bypass the confirmation. But in my example holding down the same key for three hours straight? That could cause serious joint issues from an orthopedic perspective. This unnecessary menu belongs to design bad practices—forcing users to repeatedly confirm obvious actions disrupts their workflow. It’s reminiscent of the notorious Windows confirmation prompts of the '90s and early 2000s, which became the subject of early internet memes, like the classic "Your mouse was moved. Are you sure you want to move it?" KDE remains the last desktop environment still uses `Apply` buttons. We love KDE. Please spend some time on this! |