Bug 450317

Not the same as Bug 427894; looks subtly different.

Have not seen this myself.

Until a few days ago this issue sometimes occurred in my machine with git-master and also before then with 5.23.5, But I have not seen this problem for several days(with git-master), but  I don't know is fixed or not because  I don't know how can reproduce accurately.

I haven't been able to reproduce this since we fixed Bug 427894, so I suspect there is a very particular set of steps required to experience the issue.

Postix, are you still able to reproduce with Plasma 5.24.1? There was actually a packaging issue in 5.24 that caused some commits to be omitted, but it was all cleared up for 5.24.1. I wonder if there's a chance the fix was one of the omitted commits. So I'd like to ask if you're still seeing it with 5.24.1.

(In reply to Nate Graham from comment #3)
> So I'd like to ask if you're still seeing it with 5.24.1.

It's nothing I had seen very regularly, especially since it requires a many messages in the notification applet to show up. So I will observe it the following two weeks on 5.24.1 and if I don't see it, I think we can hopefully and definitely close it.  :)

Awesome, thanks!

(In reply to Nate Graham from comment #5)
> Awesome, thanks!

Unfortunately, with updates from yesterday, I could still reproduce it today on openSUSE TW with Plasma 5.24.1.
Right now it happens in the case where I have the following structure:

```
Firefox (Downloading finished)
----
Thunderbird
- Message 1
- Message 2
<-- clip -->
- Message 3
- Message 4
- Message 5
...
```

When I unfold the list, there's a larger margin between message 2 and 3 and 3 overlaps with message 4.

The gap between message 2 and 3 after unfolding the list is actually the height of the "Show N more" button. I think that should give you a good hint, of what's going on. :)

It also happened now with

```
Firefox
- Download finished
- Download finished
Thunderbird
- Message 1
- Message 2
<---clip --->
```
where message 1 and 2 overlapped.

Created attachment 147392 [details]
Screenshot: "Thunderbird" title and "Show more" button overlapped

Here's another sample: This time the title "Thunderbird" and the "Show more" button overlapped. When the cursor hovered over the button, it still show it outlines, but it actually did nothing when clicked as it the list was already expanded from the beginning.

I can confirm the bug, it's always reproducible with notifications from Thunderbird.

Created attachment 150013 [details]
Simple shell script that generates a few notifications

I have created a very trivial sample script which generates sample messages similar to the ones which Thunderbird and also other app produce. Using those I can indeed trigger this bug and hopefully others can now reproduce it as well.

In order to make the message appear in the Notification applet, adjust the following setting:
System Settings > Notifications > Applications: Configure > "Other Applications > "Show in History"

Created attachment 150014 [details]
Screenshot of the sample message + bug

Created attachment 150015 [details]
Simple shell script that generates a few notifications

(In reply to Nate Graham from comment #3)
> I haven't been able to reproduce this since we fixed Bug 427894, so I 
> suspect there is a very particular set of steps required to experience the
> issue.

Nate, can you reproduce it now with the script above?  Could be that you need to adjust it a little bit  in terms of #notifications or header/body content, icons, if you cannot trigger the bug immediately.

I couldn't observe this anymore since 5.27.3. I guess and hope the issue gone forever. Therefore I close it for now. ;)