Bug 407815

Summary:	kdenlive version 19.04.1 cannot be installed from ppa:kdenlive/kdenlive-stable
Product:	[Applications] kdenlive	Reporter:	Andrei Rybak <rybak.a.v>
Component:	Setup & Installation	Assignee:	Vincent PINON <vpinon>
Status:	RESOLVED INTENTIONAL
Severity:	normal
Priority:	NOR
Version First Reported In:	19.04.1
Target Milestone:	---
Platform:	Other
OS:	Linux
Latest Commit:		Version Fixed In:
Sentry Crash Report:

Description Andrei Rybak 2019-05-21 22:53:33 UTC

SUMMARY
kdenlive version 19.04.1 cannot be installed from ppa:kdenlive/kdenlive-stable 

STEPS TO REPRODUCE
0. Observe list of packages at https://launchpad.net/~kdenlive/+archive/ubuntu/kdenlive-stable
1. sudo add-apt-repository ppa:kdenlive/kdenlive-stable
2. sudo apt-get update
3. aptitude show kdenlive

OBSERVED RESULT
At step 0 — 19.04.1 is listed as an available version of package "kdenlive".
For step 3
> ...
> Package: kdenlive                        
> Version: 4:17.12.3-0ubuntu1
> State: installed
> ...

EXPECTED RESULT
For step 3
> ...
> Package: kdenlive                        
> Version: 4:19.04.1-6~ubuntu19.10.1
State: installed
...

SOFTWARE/OS VERSIONS
Linux/KDE Plasma: Kubuntu 18.04
(available in About System)
KDE Plasma Version: 5.12.7
KDE Frameworks Version: 5.44.0
Qt Version: 5.9.5

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
> $ apt-cache policy kdenlive
> kdenlive:
>   Installed: 4:17.12.3-0ubuntu1
>   Candidate: 4:17.12.3-0ubuntu1
>   Version table:
>  *** 4:17.12.3-0ubuntu1 500
>         500 http://archive.ubuntu.com/ubuntu bionic/universe amd64 Packages
>         100 /var/lib/dpkg/status

---

> $ apt-cache showpkg kdenlive
> Package: kdenlive
> Versions: 
> 4:17.12.3-0ubuntu1 (/var/lib/apt/lists/archive.ubuntu.com_ubuntu_dists_bionic_universe_binary-amd64_Packages) (/var/lib/dpkg/status)
>  Description Language: 
>                  File: /var/lib/apt/lists/archive.ubuntu.com_ubuntu_dists_bionic_universe_binary-amd64_Packages
>                   MD5: 4e8f8c02918f6de02fc8e354d08ec99c
>  Description Language: 
>                  File: /var/lib/apt/lists/archive.ubuntu.com_ubuntu_dists_bionic_universe_binary-i386_Packages
>                   MD5: 4e8f8c02918f6de02fc8e354d08ec99c
>  Description Language: en
>                  File: /var/lib/apt/lists/archive.ubuntu.com_ubuntu_dists_bionic_universe_i18n_Translation-en
>                   MD5: 4e8f8c02918f6de02fc8e354d08ec99c
> 
> 
> Reverse Depends: 
>   kdenlive-data,kdenlive 0.7.2.1
>   kdenlive:i386,kdenlive
>   ubuntustudio-video,kdenlive
>   multimedia-video,kdenlive
>   kdenlive-dbg,kdenlive 4:17.12.3-0ubuntu1
>   kdenlive-data,kdenlive
>   kde-l10n-ar,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-zhtw,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-zhtw,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-zhcn,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-zhcn,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-wa,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-wa,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-uk,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-uk,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-ug,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-ug,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-tr,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-tr,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-sv,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-sv,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-sr,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-sr,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-sl,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-sl,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-sk,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-sk,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-ru,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-ru,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-ro,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-ro,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-ptbr,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-ptbr,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-pt,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-pt,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-pl,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-pl,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-pa,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-pa,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-nn,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-nn,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-nl,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-nl,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-nds,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-nds,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-nb,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-nb,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-mr,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-mr,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-lv,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-lv,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-lt,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-lt,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-ko,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-ko,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-km,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-km,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-kk,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-kk,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-ja,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-ja,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-it,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-it,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-is,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-is,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-id,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-id,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-ia,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-ia,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-hu,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-hu,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-hr,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-hr,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-hi,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-hi,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-he,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-he,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-gl,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-gl,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-ga,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-ga,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-fr,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-fr,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-fi,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-fi,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-fa,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-fa,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-eu,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-eu,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-et,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-et,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-es,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-es,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-eo,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-eo,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-engb,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-engb,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-el,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-el,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-de,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-de,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-da,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-da,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-cs,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-cs,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-ca-valencia,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-ca-valencia,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-ca,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-ca,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-bs,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-bs,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-bg,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-bg,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-ast,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-ast,kdenlive 4:15.04
>   kde-l10n-ar,kdenlive 4:15.04
> Dependencies: 
> 4:17.12.3-0ubuntu1 - breeze-icon-theme (0 (null)) ffmpeg (0 (null)) kded5 (0 (null)) kdenlive-data (5 4:17.12.3-0ubuntu1) kinit (0 (null)) kio (0 (null)) melt (0 (null)) oxygen-icon-theme (0 (null)) qml-module-qtquick-controls (0 (null)) qml-module-qtquick2 (0 (null)) libc6 (2 2.15) libkf5archive5 (2 4.96.0) libkf5bookmarks5 (2 4.96.0) libkf5completion5 (2 4.97.0) libkf5configcore5 (2 4.98.0) libkf5configgui5 (2 4.97.0) libkf5configwidgets5 (2 5.26.0) libkf5coreaddons5 (2 5.16.0) libkf5crash5 (2 5.15.0) libkf5dbusaddons5 (2 4.97.0) libkf5filemetadata3 (2 5.0.2+git20140925) libkf5guiaddons5 (2 4.96.0) libkf5i18n5 (2 4.97.0) libkf5iconthemes5 (2 5.25.0) libkf5itemviews5 (2 4.96.0) libkf5jobwidgets5 (2 4.96.0) libkf5kiocore5 (2 4.96.0) libkf5kiofilewidgets5 (2 4.96.0) libkf5kiowidgets5 (2 5.33.0) libkf5newstuff5 (2 4.95.0) libkf5notifications5 (2 5.30.0) libkf5notifyconfig5 (2 4.96.0) libkf5service-bin (0 (null)) libkf5service5 (2 4.96.0) libkf5textwidgets5 (2 5.0.0) libkf5widgetsaddons5 (2 4.96.0) libkf5xmlgui-bin (0 (null)) libkf5xmlgui5 (2 4.98.0) libmlt++3 (2 6.6.0) libmlt6 (2 6.6.0) libqt5core5a (2 5.9.0~beta) libqt5dbus5 (2 5.0.2) libqt5gui5 (2 5.8.0) libqt5network5 (2 5.0.2) libqt5qml5 (2 5.0.2) libqt5quick5 (2 5.6.1) libqt5svg5 (2 5.6.0~beta) libqt5webkit5 (2 5.6.0~rc) libqt5widgets5 (2 5.7.0) libqt5xml5 (2 5.0.2) libstdc++6 (2 5.2) dvdauthor (0 (null)) dvgrab (0 (null)) frei0r-plugins (0 (null)) genisoimage (0 (null)) recordmydesktop (0 (null)) swh-plugins (0 (null)) khelpcenter (0 (null)) kdenlive:i386 (32 (null)) 
> Provides: 
> 4:17.12.3-0ubuntu1 - 
> Reverse Provides:

Comment 1 Andrei Rybak 2019-05-21 22:56:37 UTC

I missed a step in "STEPS TO REPRODUCE" between step 2 and 3, there should be another step:

2.5. sudo apt-get install --only-upgrade kdenlive

And the observed result for this command is:
> Reading package lists... Done
> Building dependency tree       
> Reading state information... Done
> kdenlive is already the newest version (4:17.12.3-0ubuntu1)

Comment 2 Andrei Rybak 2019-05-21 23:18:10 UTC

I just realized, that this PPA explicitly does not provide packages for Ubuntu 18.04 aka "Bionic":

> Unfortunately, the QML parts are not reliable with Qt versions below 5.11, so bionic is out of scope (18.04 LTS, basis for several derivatives).

Marking this as RESOLVED and INTENTIONAL. Please changes it if other status is more appropriate.