| Summary: | Transferring files to Galaxy Nexus claims that the files already exist on the device | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Product: | [Applications] amarok | Reporter: | S. Burmeister <sven.burmeister> |
| Component: | Collections/MTP player | Assignee: | Amarok Developers <amarok-bugs-dist> |
| Status: | RESOLVED UNMAINTAINED | ||
| Severity: | normal | CC: | bart.cerneels, matej |
| Priority: | NOR | ||
| Version: | 2.6.0 | ||
| Target Milestone: | 2.7 | ||
| Platform: | unspecified | ||
| OS: | Linux | ||
| Latest Commit: | Version Fixed In: | ||
| Sentry Crash Report: | |||
mtp-connect --sendfile works. jmtpfs works, kio-mtp works as well. This clearly hints at amarok being the culprit. In case mtp functionality is simply unmaintained, please remove it from amarok. (In reply to comment #3) > In case mtp functionality is simply unmaintained, please remove it from > amarok. It currently is, but still reportedly works for some people. Removing it would be actually a regression, which we try to avoid. Complete rewrite of the MTP Collection is needed, you can help us achieving it by either writing code or financially. (In reply to comment #4) > It currently is, but still reportedly works for some people. Removing it > would be actually a regression, which we try to avoid. Even if it works for some it is broken for most and does not get better over time but worse. That bad experience falls back on the rest of the application. So removing it is the only sensible thing to do IMHO. > Complete rewrite of > the MTP Collection is needed, you can help us achieving it by either writing > code or financially. It's too late for that. Since there was no feedback and hence no perspective that it will ever work or that anyone is interested in the buggy code I simply left amarok and moved on to the tools that work for me and are maintained. Since reporting bugs and writing down which other apps work using the same libs, i.e. trying to find out whether its a lib or amarok problem is called nasty in the amarok community, I'll close this bug and act as if it never happened. If you do not want people to care about amarok, that's what you get. |
The Galaxy Nexus is detected, yet dropping files on it shows a notification that the files do already exist on the device. This is wrong. libmtp 1.1.3 Some debug: amarok: BEGIN: virtual void CollectionTreeItemModel::requestCollectionsExpansion() amarok: END__: virtual void CollectionTreeItemModel::requestCollectionsExpansion() [Took: 0s] amarok: BEGIN: void Meta::MtpHandler::slotDeviceMatchSucceeded(ThreadWeaver::Job*) amarok: BEGIN: void Meta::MtpHandler::getDeviceInfo() amarok: [MtpHandler] Unknown battery level amarok: [MtpHandler] setting default parent : 1 amarok: [MtpHandler] Device supports: "" amarok: [MtpHandler] Device supports: "txt" amarok: [MtpHandler] Device supports: "html" amarok: [MtpHandler] Device supports: "wav" amarok: [MtpHandler] Device supports: "mp3" amarok: [MtpHandler] Device supports: "mpg" amarok: [MtpHandler] Device supports: "jpg" amarok: [MtpHandler] Device supports: "gif" amarok: [MtpHandler] Device supports: "jfif" amarok: [MtpHandler] Device supports: "png" amarok: [MtpHandler] Device supports: "tiff" amarok: [MtpHandler] Device supports: "wma" amarok: [MtpHandler] Device supports: "ogg" amarok: [MtpHandler] Device supports: "aac" amarok: [MtpHandler] Device supports: "mp4" amarok: [MtpHandler] Device supports: "mp3" amarok: [MtpHandler] Device supports: "" amarok: [MtpHandler] Device supports: "xml" amarok: [MtpHandler] Device supports: "flac" amarok: END__: void Meta::MtpHandler::getDeviceInfo() [Took: 0.004s] amarok: BEGIN: void Collections::MediaDeviceCollection::slotAttemptConnectionDone(bool) amarok: [MediaDeviceCollection] starting full scan amarok: BEGIN: virtual void Collections::MediaDeviceCollection::startFullScanDevice() amarok: BEGIN: bool Meta::MediaDeviceHandler::privateParseTracks() amarok: BEGIN: virtual void Meta::MtpHandler::prepareToParseTracks() amarok: END__: virtual void Collections::MediaDeviceCollection::startFullScanDevice() [Took: 0s] amarok: END__: void Collections::MediaDeviceCollection::slotAttemptConnectionDone(bool) [Took: 0s] amarok: END__: void Meta::MtpHandler::slotDeviceMatchSucceeded(ThreadWeaver::Job*) [Took: 0.006s] Some more debug output when dropping the files: amarok: BEGIN: void Collections::CollectionLocation::startWorkflow(const TrackList&, bool) amarok: END__: void Collections::CollectionLocation::startWorkflow(const TrackList&, bool) [Took: 0s] amarok: [Playlist::PrettyListView] After the drag! amarok: [Playlist::PrettyListView] clearing PUD amarok: END__: virtual void Playlist::PrettyListView::startDrag(Qt::DropActions) [DELAY Took (quite long) 5.4s] amarok: BEGIN: virtual void Collections::CollectionLocation::getKIOCopyableUrls(const TrackList&) amarok: [CollectionLocation] adding url KUrl("file:///path/file.mp3") amarok: BEGIN: void Collections::CollectionLocation::slotStartCopy(const QMap<KSharedPtr<Meta::Track>, KUrl>&, const Transcoding::Configuration&) amarok: BEGIN: virtual void Collections::MediaDeviceCollectionLocation::copyUrlsToCollection(const QMap<KSharedPtr<Meta::Track>, KUrl>&, const Transcoding::Configuration&) amarok: BEGIN: void Meta::MediaDeviceHandler::copyTrackListToDevice(Meta::TrackList) amarok: BEGIN: virtual float Meta::MtpHandler::totalCapacity() const amarok: END__: virtual float Meta::MtpHandler::totalCapacity() const [Took: 0s] amarok: BEGIN: virtual float Meta::MtpHandler::totalCapacity() const amarok: END__: virtual float Meta::MtpHandler::totalCapacity() const [Took: 0s] amarok: END__: void Meta::MediaDeviceHandler::copyTrackListToDevice(Meta::TrackList) [Took: 4.3s] amarok: END__: virtual void Collections::MediaDeviceCollectionLocation::copyUrlsToCollection(const QMap<KSharedPtr<Meta::Track>, KUrl>&, const Transcoding::Configuration&) [Took: 4.3s] amarok: END__: void Collections::CollectionLocation::slotStartCopy(const QMap<KSharedPtr<Meta::Track>, KUrl>&, const Transcoding::Configuration&) [Took: 4.3s] amarok: END__: virtual void Collections::CollectionLocation::getKIOCopyableUrls(const TrackList&) [Took: 4.3s] amarok: BEGIN: void Collections::CollectionLocation::slotFinishCopy() amarok: END__: void Collections::CollectionLocation::slotFinishCopy() [Took: 0s] X Error: BadWindow (invalid Window parameter) 3 Major opcode: 20 (X_GetProperty) Resource id: 0x1400175 amarok: BEGIN: virtual float Meta::MtpHandler::totalCapacity() const amarok: END__: virtual float Meta::MtpHandler::totalCapacity() const [Took: 0.002s] amarok: BEGIN: void ScanManager::checkScannerVersion() amarok: END__: void ScanManager::checkScannerVersion() [Took: 0.016s] amarok: BEGIN: virtual float Meta::MtpHandler::totalCapacity() const amarok: END__: virtual float Meta::MtpHandler::totalCapacity() const [Took: Reproducible: Always