| Summary: | Put back the old behavior for showing hidden system tray icons | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Product: | [Unmaintained] plasma4 | Reporter: | Lukas Jirkovsky <l.jirkovsky> |
| Component: | widget-systemtray | Assignee: | Plasma Bugs List <plasma-bugs> |
| Status: | RESOLVED INTENTIONAL | ||
| Severity: | wishlist | CC: | aseigo, cyberbeat, redm, silver.salonen, tomas.linhart, vit |
| Priority: | NOR | ||
| Version: | unspecified | ||
| Target Milestone: | --- | ||
| Platform: | openSUSE | ||
| OS: | Linux | ||
| Latest Commit: | Version Fixed In: | ||
| Sentry Crash Report: | |||
|
Description
Lukas Jirkovsky
2010-06-20 09:46:39 UTC
Another wrong copy of wrong feature from Windows? Come on. It makes no sense to have it impemented this way. Please revert to old behaviour. *** This bug has been confirmed by popular vote. *** the change was made because expanding the system tray in place moves everything else on the panel, which does not work well at all for small fixed sized panels or panels where there isn't enough room. this triggered various bugs like icons appearing on top of other items. as for "copying windows 7", none of these changes were inspired by windows 7 (or any other version of it). similar problems solved by different people often result in similar solutions. According to the number of votes I'd say that people are willing to "suffer" from several small bugs which the old behavior may cause (BTW I never saw any of the mentioned). I'm not saying that the old behavior has to be on by default. But I don't see a reason why there can't be an option to switch it back. It was possible with application launcher. Maybe if you point me to the right file I can try to fix it myself. "According to the number of votes I'd say that people are willing to "suffer" from several small bugs which the old behavior may cause (BTW I never saw any of the mentioned)." we aren't willing to maintain the burden of development and maintenance of yet another system tray layout that has inherent flaws in the design. you and some others may not care, but we do. if the feature is offered, people will expect it to work properly in all reasonable cases and that's a valid expectation. as we can't deliver that with the old expansion style, we moved to something that can work in all cases. "I'm not saying that the old behavior has to be on by default. But I don't see a reason why there can't be an option to switch it back." because we aren't willing to maintain something that is inherently buggy by design, even if some people want it that way. our manpower is slim as it is, we don't need to make it worse by adding broken features to the mix. "It was possible with application launcher." the application launcher is a separate plasmoid and it has a maintainer. "Maybe if you point me to the right file I can try to fix it myself." it's in kdebase/workspace/plasma/generic/applets/systemtray note that there is no interest upstream in patches that restore the old behaviour. you are free (and encouraged even! :) to take the system tray plasmoid and fork it to add your own features and offer that up on, e.g., kde-look.org. or make your own from scratch. plasma allows for that kind of flexibility. one more point of business here: do not re-open bugs that have been closed by the people doing the maintenance. when a bug is closed, that is a sign by those doing the work. you do not dictate what we work on. we collaborate with our users and then make decisions, but that does not mean you get to say "no, you WILL work on this". all you've done here is waste more of my time because i now have to notice that it's been re-opened and then re-close it. Sorry for reopening, it wasn't because I want to dictate you what to do but rather to show that someone (me) wants to work on it. Thank you for pointing me to the right direction. "Sorry for reopening, it wasn't because I want to dictate you what to do but rather to show that someone (me) wants to work on it." Please leave a comment here, when you have something to show, I am very interested. Just stumbled over this report. Not that I have a big problem with the new way to show hidden items, however I agree it feels a bit inconsistent, if half of the items are shown as icons and the other half are shown in a popup menu. My first thought when seeing this new popup was that these items are probably somehow special. Anyway, how about the following: In case there is enough room to expand the systray (i.e. empty space or an applet which can be shrunk), show an arrow pointing to the left (assuming a horizontal layout) and expand on click. In case there is not enough room show an arrow pointing down and open the popup on click. IMHO this would be a solution that serves all use cases and would be sufficiently consistent. |