Summary: | keystrokes are dissappearing: focus seems to be stolen | ||
---|---|---|---|
Product: | [Plasma] kwin | Reporter: | Jos van den Oever <jos> |
Component: | general | Assignee: | KWin default assignee <kwin-bugs-null> |
Status: | RESOLVED WORKSFORME | ||
Severity: | normal | CC: | chris, gerrysw11, hanno, johnflux, langec, nikbox |
Priority: | NOR | ||
Version: | CVS | ||
Target Milestone: | --- | ||
Platform: | Compiled Sources | ||
OS: | Linux | ||
Latest Commit: | Version Fixed In: | ||
Sentry Crash Report: |
Description
Jos van den Oever
2008-01-16 22:33:24 UTC
Here's some more information. I can get back a working keyboard by right-clicking on a window title. The keyboard almost always stops working after using alt-tab to switch applications. When using the mouse to switch, this does not happen. To add some more info: Alt-F3 or any other kwin keystroke does not work either when the keyboard stops working. In the current trunk version this problem still exists. When using alt-tab to switch windows, the keyboard can stop working. This happens about 1 in 5 of every time alt-tab is used. When the keyboard stops working, one can get it working again by right-clicking on a window title bar and moving the mouse over the context menu. There is no need to click on an entry, just moving the mouse over a context menu makes the keyboard work again. This was observed by running kde4 over an nxclient. Marking this bug as 'major' because a normal user would really panic if the keyboard for the entire desktop would stop working. I'm seeing exactly this behavior, myself, on KDE 3.5.8 (with Qt 3.3.7). Fairly fresh kubuntu install, and I'm running over NX as well. (Windows nxclient -> Kubuntu nxserver). It happens pretty often switching desktops, which I have bound to CTRL+F1, CTRL+F2, etc. Switch back and forth quickly, and the keyboard will stop working. 'xev' reports NO keyboard events, no matter what keys I hit. The mouse and everything else continues working normally. I finally figured out it was a KDE issue by killing 'kwin' and recovering my keyboard. Sometimes it comes back on its own after about 20 minutes of fiddling. I'll have to try the title bar right-click method next time this happens. Followup: Just happened again, and right clicking the title bar worked like a charm. THANK YOU for posting that workaround. That's going to save me a LOT of frustration. I can also confirm this bug. It's very annoying, but thank god for that workaround. It's been happening very often. I'm a user of Konqueror 4.1.3 (KDE 4.1.3). It's very annoying (so that I dare to add my comment), although I rarely get annoyed with bugs. It is really serious, please keep attention to it. I couldn't find the exact steps to reproduce it, but it occurred often after opening a new page retyping a url in the address field. It seems to help if changing the size of the window twice but it's a very bad problem, I think. (By the way, I am currently on GNOME, although I don't think it matters but who knows). If somebody asks I'll test this issue more thoroughly to find out ways of reproducing it. I stumbled over this one and voted for this bug a while ago. Whether or not it's the same situation, my problem turned out to be KDE responding to me having depressed a key for too long a period of time. It decided I had a usability issue and rather than give me multiple responses to one keystroke it increased the delay time before giving me a "letter". Have you tried resetting the keystroke time in usability settings? Just a thought, might be drivel I'm seeing this same problem. Symptoms: -keypresses don't work in the current session, except for Alt+F1 to switch sessions. -using Alt+F1 to jump to a command line works, I can log in on the command line and use the keyboard with no problem. -Using the mouse, I can open a parallel session and the keyboard works within the new session. I can then switch back and forth using Alt+F7 and Alt+F8. I can't pinpoint a cause. I've been working this morning using my laptop and have seen it twice in the last 4 hours. The first time it happened I was in the middle of working, hit Alt+Tab to switch windows and got no response. I rebooted the laptop at that time and found this bug report on my other computer while I was waiting. Just now I left for a coffee break, it was working fine when I left, when I came back to my desk I had no keyboard response. I tried the suggestion from: Comment #1 From Jos van den Oever 2008-01-16 22:43:05 Right-clicking on a title bar fixed it. Jos, I have no idea how you figured that out, but thanks! I see that this bug has been open since 1/08 but I first noticed the problem only a few weeks ago (sometime in 4/09). So far it has only surfaced on my laptop (Thinkpad R40 circa 2003). I have in the house various other laptops and desktops, some older some newer, running various versions of Kubuntu. Only this particular laptop has had a problem so far. When I first noticed it I was running Kubuntu 8.10. I have since upgraded to 9.04 and still have the same problem. Something else that might be helpful: I frequently use Synergy, which allows me to connect my laptop to my desktop's mouse and keyboard. When this bug shows up I'm still able to control the mouse using Synergy, but the keyboard is unresponsive whether I try the desktop's keyboard or the laptop's built-in keyboard. I've seen this happen both with and without Synergy running. If I can be of help please let me know - I wouldn't be any help coding but I'm happy to test as needed. The symptoms of this bug seem similar to bug 171685. Maybe the two bugs should be merged. At least I'd recommend that you also vote for that other bug, as it is currently ranking higher. I also get this problem, and right clicking on a title bar fixes it. Thank you so much for that suggestion! I get this in KDE 4.3.2, on a laptop, not using FreeNX or anything. is this still an issue? I have not used KDE over NX for a long time and hence have not experienced the bug for a long time. I do not know if it is fixed. I am not using windows anymore and have no need for NX and no system at hand to test the bug. If one of the other reporters, is still experiencing this bug, please confirm it. Since the last report is from 4.3, there is another bug confirmed to have disappeared, the thing would be incredibly nasty and should cause more reports and reports here have started and stopped around bug 171685 start and stop times, i'll tag this "worksforme" If somebody reproducibly looses his/her keyboard, please file a bug ;-) |