Bug 153577

I can confirm this bug. Happens in akregator 4.0.85-3.3 on openSUSE 11.0 and using kde 4.0.85 and Kontact. This bug doesn't happen when akregator is running alone without Kontact. So maybe it is Kontact bug. Only way I can open main window when using Kontact is to click on kmail icon when akregator window was already maximized in Kontact .

I can confirm this bug with openSuSE 11.0 and KDE 4.1 RC1 (4.0.99.5).
I use akregator in conjunction with kontact. The system tray icon does show new messages, so I click on it to open the kontact window to show the messages.
Additional, if I click on the system tray icon for kmail, it does not show the main window either, but it starts kontact minimized. When I then restore the kontact window from the taskbar it shows the akregator component. I hope that helps in tracking down the bug.

Is this one still valid?

I can confirm comment #1 on Akregator 1.3.1 on Kubuntu 8.10's KDE 4.1.2.

Also, if you opene Akregator first and then you open Kontact, clicking on the systray icon opens Akregator alone, but you can't access to Akregator part on Kontact.

I can confirm this problem on openSUSE_11.1 and kde-4.1.86 rpms.  When using
akregator alone, I see the following behaviour:
- open akregator on desktop 1
- move to desktop 2
- select akregator systray icon, nothing happens
- select the akregator systray icon once more:
  akregator is moved to the current desktop, and it is change in size.
  This is not the desired behaviour. The user should be brought to the desktop
  where akregator is (desktop-1 in this case).

When kontact is opened, nothing happens when clicking on the systray icon....

I confirm this bug on Akregator 1.3.50 (KDE 4.1.96).

In fact left-clicking on systray icon makes akregator window to compare but it immediately minimizes again. The global effect is a very short blinking

I instead have a different behavior w.r.t. #5
Left-clicking on the systray icon when Akregator is opened repaints the window exactly as it is. Can be better, but at least the windows doesn't move or change size. This happens when the window is either in desktop 1 or 2.

I forgot: Please also tell me the akregator and kdepim version/revision you use, as well as your Qt version.
The reset on feed change was reported by a 4.5 snapshot user, which is suspicious.

I fixed it by moving akregator to different desktop. Now it works as expected.

akregator 1.3.50
kdepim4-4.1.96
libqt4-4.4.3

It's still not working for me (akregator inside kontact, that is).

Akregator 1.4.0
Kde 4.2.0 from Kubuntu Intrepid

If I close the main window and I click on the systray icon the screen flash but no window appear. I need to right click on the systray and select "restore" (or a similar name, I'm using a localized version) to show the main window.
For me this is a new bug. Akregator worked perfectly in 4.1.4

kde 4.2.0 from kubuntu ppa repository on kubuntu 8.10
akregator and kontact package version: 4:4.2.0-0ubuntu1~intrepid~ppa3
kontact 1.4
liqtcore4 4.4.3-0ubuntu1.1

using akregator within kontact
akregator system tray icon only works with right click context menu; it doesn't minimize nor restore kontact. I just use kmail system tray icon to restore and minimize it.
I had the same problem in kde 4.1

I have the same problem with the akregator system tray within kontact under 11.0 (kde 4.1+2) 11.1(kde4.1+2+3), and factory(kde4.2)
Restore: Only clicking on kmail tray restores the kontact window, but with the latest kontact component I used. Clicking on korganizer tray opens korganizer within contact. 
Minimiz: Only Clicking on Kmail systray minimizes kontact.
Should work like:
Clicking kmail tray open kmail within contact.
Clicking akregator tray open akregator within contact.

This bug seems fixed in KDE 4.2!
 
Now right-click menu doesn't offer "restore" anymore and left-click does restore and minimize correctly akregator.

I'm using kde 4:4.2.0-0ubuntu1~intrepid1~ppa2 on Kubuntu from repo "http://ppa.launchpad.net/kubuntu-experimental/ubuntu intrepid main"

After upgrading it needs to quit akregator and open it again to make it work as I described

@gabriele monfardini: which exact version of kde-4.2?

For me clicking on the rss icon, doesn't do a thing (except showing the context menu).  Perhaps it was solved in the last days, but if it wasn't, and I don't
see an svn commit update in this report, hence I assume it was not fixed, it
is still not working.  Perhaps a local kubuntu patch?

@Richard Bos
KDE version in About is "Version 4.2.00 (KDE 4.2.0)"

Right-click on the icon produce a menu with "Fetch all, Configure, Quit". Before 4.2 there was also the option to restore the main window.

Left-click on the icon toggles main window visibility (with the same position and dimension of last time it was opened). That is what I would expect to see.

This change happened I think in RC.

I have kubuntu (intrepid), with kde 4.2, but the bug isn't solved for me

Is this akregrator in kontact or standalone?

if you're asking me, it's akregator in kontact
standalone akregator works good

My akregator is also standalone so it appears that the bug is not solved only for akregator in Kontact

*** Bug 167360 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***

Strange, works for me as Gabriele describes. Both on 4.2.1 and trunk. I can't remember having had the problem with earlier versions, either.

SVN commit 952087 by osterfeld:

fix minimize/restore behavior when clicking the tray icon
BUG:189181
BUG:153577
BUG:168845
BUG:173838
BUG:178084
BUG:185372

 M  +3 -32     akregator_part.cpp  
 M  +0 -4      akregator_part.h  
 M  +0 -6      mainwindow.cpp  
 M  +0 -1      mainwindow.h  
 M  +0 -9      trayicon.cpp  
 M  +0 -4      trayicon.h  


WebSVN link: http://websvn.kde.org/?view=rev&revision=952087