Summary: | Recover lost images from flash memory / camera. | ||
---|---|---|---|
Product: | [Applications] digikam | Reporter: | Louis Roederer <louis.roederer> |
Component: | Import-MainView | Assignee: | Digikam Developers <digikam-bugs-null> |
Status: | RESOLVED INTENTIONAL | ||
Severity: | wishlist | ||
Priority: | NOR | ||
Version: | 0.9.0 | ||
Target Milestone: | --- | ||
Platform: | openSUSE | ||
OS: | Linux | ||
Latest Commit: | Version Fixed In: | ||
Sentry Crash Report: |
Description
Louis Roederer
2007-02-07 05:59:32 UTC
Arnd, Gerhard, Mik, Fabien, etc... I would to have your viewpoints about this feature. Is really a good idea to include this tool in digiKam ? And somebody have any experience with this tool ? Gilles I am pretty much against it: just stick to one tool for one job. If really a gui is needed, this should be done directly for these programms. Also it would mean to keep track of changes of that code. (Still it is handy to have these programms installed for the case it should ever happen ...;-) So in my opinion: WONTFIX. Recovering of images is very broad and complicated subject - its size begs for separate application. Definitely task not for Digikam. Looks like I'm in the minority. Too bad. I've lost and accidentally deleted pics from various memory cards several times, and it sucks not having a good linux program to recover them. The Digikam camera interface seemed like a natural place to do this type of job. I still love you guys (sheds a tear). check out: http://www.cgsecurity.org/wiki/PhotoRec while it has a text ui, it works very nicely. Louis, thanks a lot for your understanding! (Should I add an entry to the FAQ about undeleting files, so that the information is not lost and filing this bug had at least one consequence? ;-) closing this bug as WONTFIX. Marcus: In my original request, I did mention that I used PhotoRec to do this, but CLI is so 1970's. All the memory cards I buy have cool GUI recovery tools, but only for Windows. Thanks for the tip, though. Arnd: Not necessary. Just being able to have a conversation with the developers is enough, even when the answer is not the one I was hoping for. At least it was openly considered. Louis - file it as a new wish for new kipi-plugin. This is more sensible IMO. Mikolaj: Great idea. I will do it. Thanks. I have quite some experience with the team testdisk/photorec, they are just perfect tools. I recovered even an iPod hfsplus partition entirely with it (even Diskwarrior for Mac couldn't achieve that). I also find they are easy enough to use for somebody inexperienced, their only drawback is that one recovers the whole lot, not just the three files one accidentally deleted. I would follow the advice of Arnd and stick to this great tool set. If you like a GUI, write to kde-apps, maybe somebody takes up the challenge to wrap photorec in a kommander script. Gerhard I also tested it recently. It works really great and can recover everything possible from a device. If I remember correctly, the tool needs read access to the block device, so it may need some additional privileges (not just user, depending on distributions). And I agree with Gerhard, you can only recover everything, not just a few files. In my case, it took 20 minutes (because my CF reader is very very slow)... So, I'm not sure it's a good idea to embedded a frontend in digiKam or kipi-plugins. It would be better to have a standalone GUI for that. |