| Summary: | Version 2.1 new gui is unusable | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Product: | [Applications] ktorrent | Reporter: | Iñaki Baz Castillo <ibc> |
| Component: | general | Assignee: | Joris Guisson <joris.guisson> |
| Status: | RESOLVED FIXED | ||
| Severity: | wishlist | ||
| Priority: | NOR | ||
| Version: | unspecified | ||
| Target Milestone: | --- | ||
| Platform: | unspecified | ||
| OS: | Linux | ||
| Latest Commit: | Version Fixed In: | ||
| Sentry Crash Report: | |||
| Attachments: | Combobox for switching between groups | ||
|
Description
Iñaki Baz Castillo
2007-01-25 23:56:15 UTC
[quote] - The "search" button is "hidden" in the bottom-left corner. A button so important should be very visible, that is, in the TOP. [/quote] That is debateable, we didn't want to sacrifice a full tab to a widget which is not very big. First we put it on the left tab bar, but because it was to wide, it was decided to move it to the bottom. [quote] - What does it mean then "Groups" left tab (why "Groups"???). Yes, I know what it is for, but do you imagine a common user looking for the "downloads"? do you really think that he'll look into the "Groups" tab? - The VERY important "Download" tab is semi-hidden in the strange "Groups" tab. And the users must do DOBLE CLICK (not just easy single click) in "Downloads" to see them. [/quote] A common user, with not to many torrents, I think is more interested in all of his torrents. Maybe you are right that if you only want to see downloads or uploads, things are a bit hidden. But that can be solved by a combobox in the menu bar to select the current group. (Not a bad idea, I'm gonna add this) And the double click is just plain untrue. You only need a single click to switch. [quote] - Which kind of users does understand what "User downloads" tab means? I think just advanced users. What about common users? why do they need to see always these confusing "User downloads" and "User sends"? [/quote] So we need to make life more difficult for advanced users ? So that maybe common users wouldn't get confused ? How do you know they would get confused ? As for your proposal, I don't like tabs in tabs. The combox box will solve your problem for not being able to switch from uploads or downloads without going into the groups tab. I don't think finding the search tab, is that much of a problem. > That is debateable, we didn't want to sacrifice a full tab to a widget > which is not very big. First we put it on the left tab bar, but because it > was to wide, it was decided to move it to the bottom. I understand the problem, really, but I think that the search button in the bottom is a bad idea. > A common user, with not to many torrents, I think is more interested in all > of his torrents. Maybe you are right that if you only want to see downloads > or uploads, things are a bit hidden. But that can be solved by a combobox > in the menu bar to select the current group. (Not a bad idea, I'm gonna add > this) How would look that combobox? I can't imagine it. > And the double click is just plain untrue. You only need a single click to > switch. No no, single click is needed only if you have configured the mouse to "open files and directories" with one click. But if you configure the mouse as "double click to open files and directories" (that will be the KDE default) then you should do double click in Ktorrent "downloads" and "uploads". Since there are not two different actions wiht the left button, why force the usr to do double click? > So we need to make life more difficult for advanced users ? So that maybe > common users wouldn't get confused ? How do you know they would get > confused ? I think that a P2P desktop app should "hide" the complex and advanced features to common users and let them use the program easily with the default configuration. I just can comment you about two friends using Ktorrent and how they were really confused when they upgraded to Ktorrent 2.1 (because I told them to upgrade and test their opinion). Let me do a proposal. Since Ktorrent is becoming a really breat and important app in KDE, why don't you ask in kde-usability@kde.org list about the usability of 2.1 version? In that list there have been many threads about KDE apps usability with very good opinion IMHO. Anyway, thanks a lot for a great program. Created attachment 19448 [details]
Combobox for switching between groups
This is what I mean with the combobox
As for the double click, it seems that the executed signal of KListView depends upon the global setting for double or single click, wasn't aware of that. Oh, well there is bound to be another signal to get it to respond to a single click. I wouldn't mind some people with expertise in usability to go over it. > --> (http://bugs.kde.org/attachment.cgi?id=19448&action=view) > Combobox for switching between groups > > This is what I mean with the combobox Personally I don't like it. It forces the need of two clicks again for the access to a section. And these sections are too important to hide them behind a combobox. I've done some mockups ofr kde applications (for Konqueror a printers module). Maybe you could see them and if you like them I could do a mockup for Ktorrent. Just if you want. I'm allways open for suggestions SVN commit 641512 by guisson: Final part of GUI overhaul : search plugin tab has now become a toolbar. With the GUI overhaul complete, we can close 140629 BUG: 140629 M +9 -0 apps/ktorrent/ktorrent.cpp M +2 -0 apps/ktorrent/ktorrent.h M +6 -0 libktorrent/interfaces/guiinterface.h M +1 -1 plugins/search/Makefile.am M +3 -0 plugins/search/ktsearchplugin.kcfg M +4 -4 plugins/search/searchplugin.cpp M +95 -101 plugins/search/searchpref.ui M +11 -4 plugins/search/searchprefpage.cpp M +25 -16 plugins/search/searchtab.cpp M +24 -6 plugins/search/searchtab.h D plugins/search/searchtabbase.ui |