410891 2019-08-14 08:52:58 +0000 Add mountpoint to default disk label 2021-07-01 09:18:37 +0000 1 1 3 Frameworks and Libraries frameworks-solid general unspecified Other Linux RESOLVED FIXED usability NOR wishlist --- 1 i lukas a.samirh78 kdelibs-bugs-null nate till2.schaefer https://invent.kde.org/frameworks/solid/commit/e0f9d9769f666b4a0ab02a53eb5bb9fc53b611e5 5.84 0 oldest_to_newest 1874712 0 i 2019-08-14 08:52:58 +0000 I noticed that Dolphin has removed "Root" in places section. I think it is good because we can access "Root" in devices section. (Here must be some partition mounted at /, otherwise the system doesn't work) Then I found a problem: the device list only show devices' names as "250GB Hard Drive", etc. This is clear when you have only one partition. But for some users, they have dual boot, and more partitions are created. The list may look like: 40GB Hard Drive 120GB Hard Drive 240GB Hard Drive 110GB Hard Drive 20GB Hard Drive Users might be confused. My suggestion is to add mount point and file system info to device labels or in tooltip: 40GB Hard Drive Btrfs, / 120GB Hard Drive XFS, /home 240GB Hard Drive Ext4, /data 110GB Hard Drive NTFS, ??? 20GB Hard Drive FAT, ??? 1874781 1 122114 nate 2019-08-14 15:24:43 +0000 Created attachment 122114 Disks, and one is mounted at / The root volume uses a special icon so you can tell which one it is. 1874782 2 nate 2019-08-14 15:27:25 +0000 Still, it might be a good idea to make the default label include the mountpoint. So you would have: 40GB Hard Drive (/) 120GB Hard Drive (/home) 240GB Hard Drive (/data) ...etc 2038322 3 bug-janitor 2021-06-07 18:03:41 +0000 A possibly relevant merge request was started @ https://invent.kde.org/frameworks/solid/-/merge_requests/41 2040109 4 a.samirh78 2021-06-13 00:04:49 +0000 FWIW, the most robust solution is adding partition labels using any partition manager (e.g. gparted), that works across OS's ...etc, because it's a property of the filesystem not specific to an OS. 2042222 5 faure 2021-06-19 09:34:34 +0000 Git commit e0f9d9769f666b4a0ab02a53eb5bb9fc53b611e5 by David Faure, on behalf of Ahmad Samir. Committed on 19/06/2021 at 08:53. Pushed by dfaure into branch 'master'. UDisks backend: improve the description of volume and storage devices - Nowadays SSD's are pretty common, using "Hard Drive" doesn't seem correct, "Hard Disk Drive" v.s. "Solid State Drive". Instead use: "External Drive" and "Internal Drive", which should work for both cases - Add the block device name (sdX[Y]) to the description, this is useful for devices without labels; the same goes for a whole disk device, e.g. /dev/sdc, which can't have a label at all. One can easily differentiate between devices based on the device name, /dev/sda, /dev/sdc2, /dev/sdd ...etc, which are always unique An obvious use-case is the Places panel in Dolphin or KFileWidget, if you have two or more partitions without labels, you can't tell which is which easily with just the size. FIXED-IN: 5.84 M +13 -9 src/solid/devices/backends/udisks2/udisksdevice.cpp https://invent.kde.org/frameworks/solid/commit/e0f9d9769f666b4a0ab02a53eb5bb9fc53b611e5 2044483 6 till2.schaefer 2021-07-01 07:49:07 +0000 I much appreciate this change! However, I would like to argue, that mount points are far less technical and informative. Although they are not always present, one can fall back to device names in this case or present booth information if present. possibly related report Bug 433950 2044484 7 till2.schaefer 2021-07-01 07:50:55 +0000 (In reply to Till Schäfer from comment #6) > I much appreciate this change! > > However, I would like to argue, that mount points are far less technical and > informative. are more informative... 2044490 8 a.samirh78 2021-07-01 08:37:16 +0000 Adding the mount point to the text label would make the entry take more space, since this a side panel, the text would either get elided or a horizontal scrollbar would appear. The mount point is used in the tooltip, so you still get that info. 2044495 9 till2.schaefer 2021-07-01 09:09:39 +0000 sounds reasonable for dolphin. thx for the explanation. One further question, does this commit influence other places than sidebar panels (e.g. the labels mentioned in Bug 433950)? 2044500 10 a.samirh78 2021-07-01 09:18:37 +0000 Sorry, I don't know :) 122114 2019-08-14 15:24:43 +0000 2019-08-14 15:24:43 +0000 Disks, and one is mounted at / root disk icon.png image/png 4637 nate iVBORw0KGgoAAAANSUhEUgAAAKkAAAB2CAIAAAA83ySCAAAACXBIWXMAAA7EAAAOxAGVKw4bAAAR z0lEQVR4Xu2dd1hTZx+GnwwCIWGHJRsUwqYMQRAUB+Ki1i1VQYFaRVvX1/rV1Wpbdx1FUXGB1Tpq bd1aR60DRVAUKw6GFAVlh7CTnHx/hBFSQPRrTeSc+8rldc7vfc+JXDfvGclzXmhPnjwhCEIqlQIg CEK2LJFIpFKpbFW2LJFIZMuyBYIgRCKRrCIWiyWShwlRSwrCt8z3Y4nF4oyEmZtfDF40L5hWXj53 3vy027d9e/qAQsVgKhY6T3XOhX37T2c8KyqvEolEohpY1ogAVmOrvr4+UN5qAwrV4o3dl53+Zn5C fejcjz+01NegS7L3L1iVB5FiLwoVRs59XWVJZR2To6/VNHQ75OHtDAQuifa1l4jFYkmloESg2INC xaE3Lz1PmhwUFLTsllxjRxgbGYke3XnUAKCh+PrOI5mKHShUnZZxX1kpBMzMusk1doRdxMIZZRu+ nToVamq6TqHD+z3ZlaXYh0KlaXZfnJLynNV7bZQtIJXv0C4s28H/2TCo6TpfIhnUTywWi8ViAE5T N26SSGTLFCpLk/u6lCv3bCafGKINonPqKd55mtxrDN3xcChBEATRqpmiC9NyrUdBNij35IVyT14o 9+SFck9eKPfkpSu4r808vmH97uQixTpFx7zx93j/D9Inp+KOpgtqxVIag8XW0jextHP17uluzqUp 9uwUDE0dnoG0c19BUbSgHPe1wopafZ9xQ5zZREONoOjp/bSTu9LSg8PDA83ewCDLKmjiZMUixStR insAgLqeuaUFFwDsHN29XC8m7bn00wXL2MFWTACSiieXz13OeFpSy9I15weE9nflqUlzTq7f+8Ql enaIGQBAmn1y9b5n/rHTAstPfLu/qN/sqX7aAFBXkHr2bPLDAqFYjWvoMSQypDsL0qqnyWcv3skp qqJrmfTwDQnxNtUAUPcs+dS5lOyXQhGTo+8QMinMmdP8/+v6KM99K1jmffq6pP6Yfjt7kJUDvSHn xJ6DuaZ9Bo4ZxKnO+v30L/ugMzPU0prvwE7LyS6BGQ8ACnJz64zcHA1axYOIF3/s3nVVZB8QOtpC C1UVTB4LkBRcStx7h+s/YNQAvfr85DOn9p3izhzJ18i5cPDcM6vQsAHmHKKqRKSv2bIfMqAi7gGG mZkJ7paUVMJBknIhXeIxaXSgLQOAxfuC7E3X7v0Vamljw7fXuP34cUUQTxcoevSo3NCZz2u1l7qM 368VGwbOGBsoV69Nv5gssA+L7u+qDsDSpC5v9fF7T97nOwqFtTQtM769pQ4NMG/ZgCSojPsWpIWF L1BdtH/lvaYCAUKjoh5Qt3bsoX7g0SOhv69W8cPMUn0nR6NWm+JFfr5Y28O29S/Ey8JCQlR3fM03 x2XrUkIqNRZUgsn3C7h58Hz8llx3L2+f9+x56q026/KojHvJ82cvwOrB0waYDCYMPCeM89JpaVbj sgAw7Jz5Ggfu/ynwtf3zQQnP2dm4pQcAgMlg4G83C0wmExzX4ZG9TeVqmtoAwzo45hPnh3du3Uj+ acs1q8ERE3x4XeGmt5OoyI/akP/7pT/rtD087eigGRkborywVI0nh44GDQCYPTzdtAvS72bczSg2 f89DYdQDBsbGdEFuTmmrIs/IiF5dWEIYyO1PV5MBAKCxjRz9h06ZMdaNlnPtdkGr7bo6yhv3dWX5 T/PYhKhG8PLpn7dv59SZB4f3t2IC0PcKcr1x8Py+n+t7O3fjMhoqi+sNvDwsWABAM/fxNE65drJM ajfUXVdhlwDbPcj32p4r+w4RQW4WOmoNFbVcRxdz98CeVxOTfzyIQHdLXZa4qkTIdfa25RLPM26W ss15HEZDeV5pAzgccl3sKcU9ja2lw85OO5SU2vTZjsuwqT3dzTmNh2sN+xExEy6fuZR6+kiVRI2j rW/fz8WjKfnP8/KxvXLihWtPl7ZMMSz6R0Vwz/x26+yRqw10tp5tHysXc33LAVERWmd/u3X+6PUG Bltbz6K3nTe4NYK8B5cyf6+sB4ujZ+Y+ItRPX3F3XRraP/RcjkS2IKN5tZx6LkeFUZHzPYUSoNyT F8o9eaHckxfKPXmh3JMXyj15odyTF8o9eaHckxfKPXmh3JMXyj15Ucp3uC14eHopluRIv52mWPo3 EVz8avyqp+Gbd0/qrtjUJVH+uA8MDDz/27n022nNr/O/nQsMDFTsJ0/y1wGefeefrVAo16etDvX0 +vRErUK9k6jpdLOxtjJsKxbQJVG++6VLFvMMDACkpqVFxcQA4BkYLF2yWLGfHNVFRdUQnt8Yn9Yg V5Xm7llz+AVQWlomV30NNL1itmz7MrSzs0298yjfvUw8gPitW6d//LFCsU2KiouhZ2Vd80vcT8+b i5W/bd2ba2HdDaVlje6LTi0dNWRAgJ+vb/CI6d+dz5fN/Ci5u2NmxMhhIUEBft5+/cOmrTiR0/Qb dH15L8+IfS8BADmHZo4c0ifAz9t/4Oi5W28Uy+aiqb616/MpY4b1C+zl7d//w4QHANDw/OKmTz4Y 4O/j13/EjHVn8+ob96byKPl8D2BiROQPiXtS09IAeHs1nv5jPprWqlNrysvLYTp+wYCLM3bvSB61 tJc6IM3+YfsFrZFbIl/OWFHaGNXUcRgUvWCosTZD+PjYhnULl5o675pgCsnzu9fva0xYvaqvlrg0 89iW+MVfGLociLZu9Q4Az2309IWTDbkovbt/3aZ5K63PrAvVQtWD388/0I5cOd9fixDU8awAwdlF kxfcsp4461tfA0Hqj5v/OzGv4eim4a1T4qqJ8t3LkB/0r6S8vAI6um7jYkIT5+84Oq3XeJPqS7t+ fOY1O76nYTyn/kVZNcAB1O38B9sBADxcq2+eWpR2VzLBVBbPNXIO7OXDAnr6sB5fnX/hYn70VAv5 dwC0+X0HypbcrV9eDklIe4hQWe5Mzcor2LfpEvX+xvXnJaHrNs0L5gDo7WdcPix2447UoQu8lX9E fRXKd//3QQ8gYfu29m8BagQCEUOLq8kOjA63HZW49+7o8Du7z3FGbA0zRCaXi4qKcoADlNxK2rTj RMqTl0JocQgQ/KoaQKv1vjRsbExxs7gYaO1e8vyPbXGJ5+7kFtcwdDTqITSqatXeSMn9+y/g0su3 6TE+dR8/d/qv9zIK4S17aFCVUb57yA36Zt8d3t0JhUJwTLkAbMdPDU76MmFFxeOHLlPWeKkBXC4X QqEQwPMDc2dtFobMXzLrPUNm1eUN0+MU9wMAUFfXgEikMAm09OGWWfMOaI5ZsHw+Xw/FJ7+dsbd1 hyZkGdd3FOW737pt+86EBNlys/Kt27a39FBEKBSCrcEGAK3+0WO2hO85ozNk3QcmAMBms1FZWQkg 60FmQ/eZ08b4mwFAoTEDsou4zlDz6M+nxHtfzhzuownAzKbd7Lahi7MRjt24WRMWrAkADakpdwm9 vk5yTwCpLqrgftvWbdsUqx1RJawCm60BAKA7TZgTU3HTcmKQbJ2tqYnqKqEU6MHnM84dT/i5+0hH HovILZHI7+IVcPiO5rRDR7acMg610WVW5QuAdu76XSNnBx9b+PVsI+FkPwNB6v7vf63zXRLtq/on e6iCe/nDu+yYL6u0f76vrqkGm81uXDMMil0S1NzG0dQEIRRWA93GfbPi5art2z47U1YHDS09U6f+ Rp34aWmgAXCYtnaxYG3i2nmHK+rpbB0DG5de7Yx9vSErktQ2r4rb8NkPNeqm7oOXJ80aqviUoIqi 5Gcz2hcMvOKs/88jOve574LaZcmbhpHjgdxOjIR/k7dstz2Ikuz0v/KuHLgO/hQ3coiH0t2rCGV/ bJixOkPXPnjRVxMsFRu7LJR7AOCN/P7GSMVil+eduCCl+Feg3JMXyj15odyTF8o9eaHckxcl3+Op yOd61fm3Uwp0/X1tSfO5DqB09wACAwObI3sySkpLv1q2/MqVK3K95CGurh395bHCsuoGqHG09Yzs 3APej5wWxm/n65ZOkLbjkzn5M85T7t8yCuLRlNUcMDBEviiHVFCQV2L2YdwXA7VENeXPMi8c2L0k KqP6wK4JCtkbig5R/vm+zVhmm8VWcM1cXF3dPX37hkUuXzLWvPburfuNkUui5FbCZ+EDA/x69gmb 8vWRR9XN20gF9w8unjwswM8vYPDE/ybdKZf/Y4Dp6wZ4enl4ennE/lIjV+7CKH/cy7KaCsWOs5ot SMXVRY8vHrxUyPac7M4CgLrUFRHTT+m8H7ss1rw+8+ctqydNrzq8J8KKDsnjhOgpuxv6T1sc04P+ 9NzW+I+mlO88/KmbmmxX/Midy4boAOAYyqIAXR7lu39D0tb2814LKUFIAZpur/krRnQDgPyDm46U ei9KXDySByCgt23diPCEzRfGrB4oPv797my7qJ9XRFrTgMAAJ1p+2Mbvj4YnjDUEAGgYWHW3exfi tf8Yyj/m/33QA0jY/qokj1PkzgMHDh3cn7Rt3aIP7R6ujYo9mCcFcT8jk7Dz82tySOf7+ejU3svI Ah5n3G8w9vW1bppq2dyvp4UkI4PEf7v9nR33bJ5NdztdAHBw8/Fh5PT96sjZvHFRaDc82VGskkb7 2+TbJED5477NWGabxfapr28A6HQGGE7ODrTsmzeaJtImHqWkCtRdnLsD9i7Oai9TbuY1bVOQkvKM 7uTsAMjSvRUCQVMTSVD+uH/9rCYAQJh/Lz2dK6oTluSlnzuwL1XDe0GoBYDxn3xwOPa7T1eIo/uZ N2T+HJdU4PjRhoGaAMJmRvwwaefsReqxQ+3pT8/Gb84wm5DwgTEA2Dk5qe8/Hr/fcWwPRuFLzaBh Xnqt361Lonz3r5/VpOmYmBvcOjJ76o9SBoutzbOw95iyMjIixBwANH0XJsYZrdqwfeGvlQwDfr85 ifPG2dABgOn48a6d2qvW7Fs6u0yqa9s7Kv7zSA/ZhznaIXOW3Vv6XfyCy9A2d57EJ4d7KqtJXpQ8 7im7SkT513oUyoJyT14o9+SFck9eKPfkhXJPXij35IVyT16U/NkO9bmeElH+uH/9eTUlJ+d6eUzd XyJfe7pjlGevxe2lOynaQvnu28tqylco/g2UfMxHO7HMNoudhyi5tXP1+kPXcgRMI+eBEQvmjHLg AEDB6W8WJ97MfV4sqGfqWbgNnThYK/3YyesPngnVTNwGfbLkPwPNZfPvESWpe9fFHU3OKmUaOQRO mDt3jJPC5GxdAOWP+4kRkYqlzmQ1pRJRQ0N980skaUnl1KWuiJi+55njlGXr1n4epnNj9aTpiXkE AFQ8SUkrtY9ZE7f9+68m2eXvXf71KZH/lC9Wr18+yeavnxatOS0EAIgebIn5eG+JV/TKuI3/Ha51 fWXst5dkLV0K5Y/7N+TuhsF+G1qXWM4AOopragIA28rTz8sB8HIo++P8Kq7/2LBgTcDf6vml4fHJ aRjWF4JjcUmFQV/+MGsIB4AHvzKtz/ITV5cFD25M9HYVlO++vaxmx7cA6BEetyhEu3m18PgXC44D QGNcM7Z1XHP3tYwsDHRr7g4AumZmmkRuWYVs/jRTExOIysurAO6TB5mSeuGyYL/lso6EmCB6FLxQ nHrznUf57t8Qjinf1bUlUq11s+lxKmn7cU0FWCw1SCSN8+4xmUxALBYDYKmzoDd46c4ox5a+arom LStdBOWf79uMZbZZ7BwdxDU7iXX37syyzFyxpbWNddPLTLeLHfChCuP+DbOa7WPVflyzc2gPixm/ Kzpp9hxp1PueZuz64twi3qCxfv/XnYcqonz3r5/VfBXtxzU7Ccvj06QEw7XrD21cmFTL1Day8Jjq PxZdzj2V1SQvSh73lF0l8jqHQoquBeWevLwN95oczZLiVt+6UagCb+N879DD/vHjx9m5uYoNFErl bbin0+l8Pl+xSqFs3sYxn0I1odyTl7dxzBeLxVlZWdU1JJm+6p3hbbjPysoyNjE25JFqIqN3gLdx zK+uqaHEqyBvwz2FakK5Jy+Ue/JCuScvlHvyQrknL5R78kKXNqHYQtHVaXQPgPoNIBtMGo0msy6b S5rSTx7odnZ2HA5HFs+V/UvpJwl0Op1uYWHB5XJlWWxQB3/SQD98+DCNRrOysuJwOLLsPSj95OB/ 55aIZV7jIm4AAAAASUVORK5CYII=